Articles tagged with: supreme court

Vyapam lawyer expense so far: Rs 60 lakh;12 lawyers fee range: Rs 0 to Rs 38 lakh

Counting the Rs 40.4 lakh of fees paid to 10 lawyers for 151 cases, Ignoring the higher fees paid to the two highest paid lawyers, that works out to a mathematical average of only Rs 2,675 per case.

Government work: Rs 2,675 per case is what scam-hit MP education board pays its lawyers on average

Counting the Rs 40.4 lakh of fees paid to 10 lawyers for 151 cases, Ignoring the higher fees paid to the two highest paid lawyers, that works out to a mathematical average of only Rs 2,675 per case.

SC notice in 5-lawyer plea with Sibal to remove MP governor over Vyapam scam

The Supreme Court on Friday issued notice to Madhya Pradesh Governor Ram Naresh Yadav on a plea seeking his removal for his alleged involvement in forest guard recruitment scam - one of the cases in the Vyapam scam. The apex court bench of Chief Justice HL Dattu, Justice Shiva Kirti Singh and Justic...

SCOI Report: Constitution bench concludes hearing on neo-collegium, sends mixed signals about reform

The final day of the hearing on neo-Collegium at Court No.4 in Supreme Court began at 10.40 am yesterday (19 November), with the presiding Judge, Justice JS Khehar claiming that the 10-minute delay in assembling was due to some discussions which the five judges had among themselves about the hearing.

40% vacancy crisis nudges SC to order collegium to begin judicial appointments

The Supreme Court on Thursday asked its collegium to go ahead with the appointment of judges to the high courts and the apex court which have been put on hold ever since the government notification setting up the NJAC was challenged. The constitution bench headed by Justice JS Khehar said “it is nee...

How Upendra Baxi's 'proposal' for collegium reform ended up in the Datar-Anand report

Professor Upendra Baxi, in a comment to Legally India, had expressed his surprise how his name appears in the list of those who made proposals for reforming the Collegium, compiled by Supreme Court appointed committee comprising senior advocate, Arvind Datar and ASG, Pinky Anand, as he had not submitted any such proposal. Prof Baxi was also surprised that his so-called proposal was also shown not contributing to any of the five categories, identified by the Court and the Committee, namely, Collegium Secretariat, Eligibility Criteria, Transparency, Mechanism to deal with complaints and Miscellaneous.

Maggi's back but for how long? FSSAI challenges ban lift in SC

Nestle Maggi’s comeback was challenged in the Supreme Court yesterday by the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI), reported The Economic Times . The FSSAI has filed an appreal against the Bombay high court order that had lifted the ban that was imposed over five months ago on the pop...

SCOI Report: Maverick lawyer Nedumpara at it again, seeks extension of deadline for reforming collegium [READ PETITION]

Mumbai maverick lawyer Mathews J Nedumpara has filed an application in the Supreme Court for review or recall of order dated 5 November 2015 in which the court has invited suggestions from the public for reforming the Collegium system, by 13 November and for holding two-day hearing of select counsel on 18 and 19 November.

What it reveals and what it doesn't: Arvind Datar-Pinky Anand report on neo-collegium

The report submitted to the Supreme Court’s Constitution Bench by Senior Advocate Arvind Datar and ASG, Pinky Anand on the neo-collegium received over 60 representations and suggestions from various associations and individuals.

NJAC judgment birthed new doctrine of Derivative Basic Structure (DBSD): Raju Ramachandran

In a panel discussion on the recent NJAC judgment on 5 November, organized by the Vidhi Centre for Legal Policy, New Delhi at the India International Centre Annexe, eminent senior advocate, Raju Ramachandran, had outlined grave implications for the application of the Basic Structure Doctrine.

Madras HC judge Karnan protests caseload discrimination against him; goes on long leave

Madras high court’s controversial Justice C S Karnan has filed long-leave application with the Madras high court to protest the allocation of “insignificant and dummy portfolio” of cases to him by Madras HC Chief Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul, reported Business Standard . In a letter to the Chief Justi...

Abolish 'heinous' 'patriachal' personal law that allows polygamy: Gujarat HC

Polygamy - the practice of taking several wives - is “heinously patriarchal” observed the Gujarat high court even as it quashed the bigamy charges against a muslim man, reported the Times of India . Gujarat high court justice JB Pardiwala quashed the charges against the man because bigamy and polyga...

Why neo-collegium hearings will be held up over CJI change-over

In the midst of the melee in Court 4 on 5 November before the constitution bench hearing the proposals on reforming the collegium, counsel arguing for and against the brief adjournment, missed a crucial fact: the present collegium headed by the outgoing CJI, Justice HL Dattu, is unlikely to meet to recommend the names of new Judges, in view of Dattu’s recommendation to the government to elevate the senior-most of his colleagues, Justice TS Thakur, as the CJI, after his retirement on 2 December.

Legal legend Upendra Baxi not optimistic about chances of SC fixing the collegium

At a discussion on the Supreme Court’s recent judgment quashing the 99th Amendment Act and the NJAC Act, eminent academic, Professor Upendra Baxi, defended the judgment, but expected nothing much to come out of the ongoing hearing on reforming the collegium.

Read Gopal Subramanium's 7 neo-collegium suggestions [READ SUBMISSION + Pinky Anand & Arvind Datar]

Gopal Subramanium suggests improvements
Gopal Subramanium suggests improvements
Senior counsel Gopal Subramanium has suggested in his 3 November submissions to the Supreme Court that is hearing a consultation on how to reform the collegium system the following seven ways in which the collegium should be improved to improve transparency, formulation of eligibility criteria, establishment of a permanent collegium secretariat and a mechanism to deal with complaints or adverse reports

Rohatgi, BCI Mishra, Fali to head neo-collegium committee: SC extends time

The Supreme Court on Thursday extended till 13 November the time for inviting suggestions to make the functioning of collegium system transparent and eligibility criteria based for the appointment of judges to the higher judiciary. An apex court constitution bench headed by Justice AS Khehar said th...

Kapil Sibal to appear for Hardik Patel in SC

Congress leader and senior counsel Kapil Sibal has been slated to take up cudgels on behalf of young Patel leader Hardik Patel, who faces sedition charges, in the Supreme Court. The Gujarat Police slapped the charges for Patel’s allegedly incendiary remarks and speeches during his four-month protest...

Justice TS Thakur to start 13-month CJI tenure from 3 December

Justice TS Thakur, the seniormost judge after Supreme Court Chief Justice HL Dattu, will become the next Chief Justice of India and would be at the helm of the country’s judiciary till 4 January, 2017. Chief Justice Dattu has recommended the name of Justice Thakur, being the seniormost judge after h...

The future is now: Smartest bigshots of the bar put some good & different ideas to neo-collegium bench today

SC open to good advice
SC open to good advice
As the Supreme Court’s five-Judge Constitution Bench presided over by Justice JS Khehar began its hearing on reforming the collegium (the in-house mechanism to recruit Judges to the higher judiciary after its recent revival by the same bench) the bench sought advice from counsel on both sides on how to navigate the plethora of diverse proposals which it received.

Tamil govt fights in SC for turf of state police, as Madras HC demands CISF cover

The Tamil Nadu government has asked the Supreme Court for relief from a Madras high court order directing it to put in place Central police (CISF) security worth Rs 16.6 crore at the Madras high court, reported the Times of India . Madras HC Chief Justice Kishan Kaul and Justice TS Sivagnanam had on...