Articles tagged with: supreme court

Read gov't affidavit to SC: Political parties are really better off outside RTI

The central government on Monday told the Supreme Court that political parties were not covered under RTI as they were not public authorities and any attempt to bring them under the transparency law was fraught with dangers of misuse with “malicious intention” of thwarting their “smooth internal wor...

SCOI Report: 'Booze trade not legit'; Kapil Sibal takes stage in forceful defence of Kerala liquor ban

Yesterday (August 21) senior advocate Kapil Sibal continued his arguments before the Supreme Court bench hearing the challenges to the Kerala Government’s liquor policy, making it clear that he did not want to whittle down Article 14.

Controversial RamJet win: SC declines to give pro bono Harish Salve minutes to re-open Uphaar jail release

The Supreme Court yesterday (20 August) declined the CBI’s plea to put forward its arguments on the period of sentence for Ansal brothers - Sushil and Gopal - following their conviction for negligence in 1997 Uphaar fire tragedy which claimed 59 lives.

Even Shreya Singhal shocked: 2,402 people been arrested under section 66A of IT Act in 2014

The Hindustan Times ’ Aloke Tikku reported: A first-of-its-kind set of statistics compiled by the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) reveals that 2,402 people, including 29 women, were arrested in 4,192 cases under section 66A — which was struck down in March by the Supreme Court that ruled that i...

Justice Karnan seeks 3 months to reply to 'intemperate observation' allegations by brother judges

Justice CS Karnan of the Madras high court sought 12 weeks’ time to reply to a petition alleging “intemperate observations” made by him against the Madras high court Chief Justice SK Kaul, reported PTI . According to the PTI , Karnan had written to the registrar general of the Supreme Court and said...

Will NJAC live or die by the sword of the judges it seeks to regulate? All you want to know of NJAC but were afraid to ask [via Mint]

The justices will have to choose one of many bad options
The justices will have to choose one of many bad options
Debate around the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) has often been emotive rather than dispassionate, with the discourse ranging from senior lawyer Ram Jethmalani calling it an “evil absurdity” to attorney general Mukul Rohatgi pointing to judges who habitually turned up late in court as a reason to ditch the existing collegium system to select judges.

SC extends Subrata Sahara's jail-office facilities so he can somehow raise cash he owes

The Supreme Court on Monday extended till September 30 the special facilities given to Sahara chief Subrata Roy to facilitate communication for negotiating transactions to raise money to pay market regulator Securities and Exchange Board of India. Seeking details of a loan transfer from the Bank of ...

SCOI Report: H Salve picks up from Rohatgi, continues hoteliers' attack on Kerala liquor ban

Arguments continued by the appellants in the Kerala liquor ban case Kerala Bar Hotels Association vs State of Kerala for the second day on August 18 in the Supreme Court’s Court No. 11, with senior advocates, Harish Salve and N Venkataraman making a determined attempt to expose the State Government’s “discriminatory” liquor policy.

HC judge vacancies up 18 places in 3 months as 384 seats on benches now vacant

The PTI reported the law ministry releasing data that: according to the latest data compiled by the Law Ministry, as on [1 August], the high courts were facing a shortage of 384 judges as against the approved strength of 1017. Thus, the 24 high courts are functioning with a working strength of 633 j...

'Incompetent, inefficient or corrupt'? 'Rigged' Medical Council of India (MCI) election under SC scanner [SCOI REPORT]

Ex-Medical Council of India (MCI) president Dr Ketan Desai is facing a Supreme Court probe into all manner of allegations into the future of the profession’s regulator.

SC upholds influential convicts' guilt in Nitish Katara murder, will talk sentencing in 6 weeks

The Supreme Court today upheld the conviction of the son of Uttar Pradesh politician DP Yadav, Vikas Yadav, his cousin Vishal Yadav and accomplice Sukhdev Pehlwan in the Nitish Katara murder case but issued notice to the Uttar Pradesh government on the quantum of sentence. Upholding the conviction o...

SCOI Report: Exciting days as AG Mukul Rohatgi & other SAs help 4-star hotels desperate to reverse ‘discriminatory’ Kerala liquor ban

Arguments in The Kerala Bar Hotels Association vs State of Kerala began with a lot of excitement on both sides last week before the bench of justices Viramajit Sen and Shiva Kirti Singh.

Record useless parliament session: Much hot air but only 4 bills passed, GST unlikely to make April 2016

Parliament faced record-low levels of productivity this session, with mainly the Delhi pecuniary jurisdiction bill and cheque bouncing bill squeezing through.

SC reserves judgment in Swamy, RaGa, Kejriwal et al criminal defamation challenge

The Supreme Court on Thursday reserved its verdict on a batch of petitions including by Congress vice -president Rahul Gandhi, Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal and BJP leader Subramanian Swamy challenging the constitutional validity of Indian Penal Code’s provisions on criminal defamation. A ben...

SC issues notice to gov't in P Bhushan 'unsuitable' CVC appointment PIL

The Supreme Court on Thursday issued notice to the central government on a petition by NGO Common Cause seeking quashing of the appointment of Central Vigilance Commissioner (CVC) KV Chaudhary and Vigilance Commissioner (VC) TM Bhasin as it breached the principle of “institutional integrity”. The no...

SCOI Report: One BJP-led state supported others' cases for local remission powers

As the oral submissions in the Union of India vs V Sriharan @ Murugan matter concluded on Wednesday (August 12) in the Supreme Court, it became obvious that the Rajasthan government chose to adopt the submissions of other State Governments who have, by and large, opposed the Union of India’s plea for restricting the state governments’ power under the Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr.PC ) to remit life sentences.

Salve gets CJI Dattu to stay yesterday's Guj HC order in land grant to judges [READ ORDER | UPDATE-2]

PTI and others reported that a Supreme Court bench of Chief Justice of India (CJI) HL Dattu and justices PC Ghose and Abhay Manohar Sapre has stayed yesterday’s Gujarat high court order serving notice on 27 of its current and former judges over land allotted to them by the state government in 2008. ...

Sentencing SCOI Report: Centre battled it out with states, YM Chaudhary, RamJet, ors on nature of remission power

On yesterday’s penultimate day of hearing of Union of India vs V Sriharan @ Murugan, the battle lines were clearly drawn between the Central Government and the State Governments, most of whom are listed as respondents in this case.

SC orders IIPM 'bogus litigation' vs Caravan transferred from Silchar to Delhi HC

A Supreme Court bench headed by Justice Madan Lokur has transferred to the Delhi high court the four-year old Rs 50 crore defamation suit by the Delhi-based Indian Institute of Planning and Management (IIPM) that was filed in Silchar, Assam, which had in 2011 passed an injunction against the Delhi-based publisher of The Caravan magazine for a hard-hitting profile of its founder Arindam Chaudhuri.

27 of Guj HC judiciary slapped with show cause over 2008 property hand-outs from gov't

The Indian Express and others reported: A bench of the Gujarat High Court, led by outgoing acting Chief Justice VM Sahai, today issued notices to 27 judges (both sitting and retired) of the court; the state Revenue Department; and the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation among other government agencies, ...