Articles tagged with: supreme court

SC collegium judge bats for Gopal Subramanium, urges CJI to push back against government | ‘Sources’ say GS will withdraw | IB calls him odd

A judge on the Supreme Court’s collegium, talking on condition of anonymity to the Economic Times , has come out in support of elevating senior counsel Gopal Subramanium to the Supreme Court, despite the government’s attempts to veto his earlier nomination . The judge said that Subramanium’s “credib...

Gopal Subramanium judgeship elevation file returned to collegium by law min

The law ministry has returned the file to elevate senior counsel Gopal Subramanium to the Supreme Court bench to the collegium, which will again have to reconsider whether it wants to elevate the advocate, though the ministry cleared the elevation of senior counsel Rohinton Nariman and high court ch...

CJI Lodha’s next move: SC sets up 2 permanent miscellaneous benches

RM Lodha
RM Lodha
The SC has said that from 8 July, two benches would only hear miscellaneous matters in service matters, cheque bounce appeals and labour matters.

Maha ignores SC order; to re-ban dance bars

The Maharashtra government is dropping a provision in the Bombay Police Act 1951 that allowed dance performances in “exempted” establishments like three-star and five-star hotels but banned it elsewhere, and proposing to have a blanket ban on dance bars in the state, reversing the Supreme Court’s Ju...

CJI Lodha hires NLU D prof Anup Surendranath for first SC research, efficiency drive in 30 years

Anup Surendranath
Anup Surendranath
The Supreme Court is for the second time in its history attempting to create its own dedicated intellectual and institutional research unit with the appointment of NLU Delhi assistant professor Anup Surendranath to the post of deputy registrar (research).

Thakur, Sikri J prove hard-nosed in Sahara debut: Pay Rs 10,000 cr (not from gunny bags)

Supreme Court justices TS Thakur and AK Sikri told the Sahara Group after a two hour hearing that they would have to pay Rs 10,000 crore to get its boss Subrata Roy and two directors released from jail. The judges, who replaced the previous bench of justices KS Radharkrishnan and JS Khehar amid unpr...

Justice KS Radhakrishnan exit interview on overreach, transgender, sex harassment & more

Retired Supreme Court judge Justice KS Radhakrishnan, in a brief interview in the Indian Express, talked about some of his landmark cases and challenges facing the judiciary. [Indian Express]

Bench under pressure: I don't ever want to hear a Sahara matter again, Justice Khehar tells registry

Supreme Court Justice Jagdish Singh Khehar told the Supreme Court registry on 6 May, the evening after passing its scathing judgment against Sahara chief Subrata Roy and his lawyers, that he did not want to be on the new bench that would hear the Sahara matter after the bench headed by retiring Just...

#InternJudge files SC transfer petition vs Swatanter Kumar: Won’t get fair trial in Delhi HC, senior counsel refuse to act as suit ‘engineered’ in favour of ex-judge

Swatanter Kumar
Swatanter Kumar
A former intern, who had alleged that ex-Supreme Court judge Swatanter Kumar has sexually harassed her in 2011, has applied to the Supreme Court to transfer Kumar’s defamation case.

RM Lodha's ace in hole: Rohinton Nariman, Gopal Subramanium, 2 others to become SC judges

Gopal Subramanium
Gopal Subramanium
Facing a long string of retirements during his term, Chief Justice of India (CJI) RM Lodha has recommended the elevation of two former solicitor generals to the apex court.

‘Bad court management’? SC hearings wasted, Reliance proposes arbitration in gas pricing war

Reliance Industries, BP and Niko Resources on Saturday served the Indian government with an arbitration notice in order to allow them to increase the price of natural gas that was shelved by the Election Commission until the elections finish on 16 May. Senior counsel Harish Salve, who has been repre...

SC hit by hattrick retirements as it breaks up for summer (and Winter is Coming)

Supreme Court justices AK Patnaik, KS Radhakrishnan and SS Nijjar are effectively retiring today with the long Supreme Court summer vacations starting from today, leaving the bench that had briefly enjoyed a full and unprecedented strength of 31 during the tenure of former CJI P Sathasivam , severel...

SC rejects Prashant Bhushan arguments, says Kudankulam nuclear station safe enough

A Supreme Court bench of justices KS Radhakrishnan and Vikramajit Sen gave the green light to the Tamil Nadu-based Kudankulam nuclear power plant, after being satisfied with the safety measures and compliance of the central government and responsible authorities. Activist G Sudarrajan represented by...

NUJS sex harassment case hits SC with caveat

The sexual harassment case against NUJS Kolkata assistant registrar Siddhartha Guha, who was arrested late last year after a female staff member accused him of sexual harassment and violent threats, has climbed to the apex court over cancellation of his bail. The woman, represented by advocates Sidd...

Read SC landmark animal rights verdict: Bulls' rights under PCA 'can't be taken away or curtailed'

Supreme Court justices KS Radhakrishnan and Pinaki Chandra Ghose have banned Tamil Nadu bull fighting at the Jallikattu festival, which “severely harmed” the bulls and was illegal under the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act (PCA) BBC . The judges wrote: “Bulls cannot be used as performing animals...

[Update] ELP acts & explains: Consti Bench 4-1 overrules Kone Elevator tax decision on sales / works contract distinction

A five-judge constitutional bench of CJI RM Lodha, AK Patnaik, Sudhansu Jyoti Mukhopadhaya, Dipak Misra and FM Ibrahim Kalifulla has overruled the Supreme Court’s earlier Kone Elevators decision in a four-to-one majority against Kalifulla. The majority opinion, written by Misra, ruled that the sale ...

SC Consti Bench: Kerala gov should have raised Mullaperiyar dam water levels [JUDGMENT]

A five-judge constitution bench of CJI RM Lodha and justices HL Dattu, Chandramauli KR Prasad, Madan B Lokur and MY Eqbal ruled in favour of the Tamil Nadu government that the Kerala government must not restrict the water levels in the Mullaperiyar dam. The bench said that the Kerala law from 2006 w...

Snooping target & father ask SC to stay all snoopgate probes citing privacy

The alleged victim of snooping by the Gujarat government has approached Supreme Court justices Ranjana Prakash Desai and NV Ramana with her father to restrain the central and state governments from launching an inquiry into the alleged abuse of surveillance powers, claiming that any probe would be v...

SC 5-judge bench: Right to Education Act & Rules consistent with Constitution; Can't force kids to study Kannada [JUDGMENTS]

The Supreme Court has upheld the validity of the Right to Education Act under Article 15(5) and 21-A of the Constitution about compulsory education to six to 14-year-olds. Sitting in two related cases, the constitution bench of CJI RM Lodha and justices AK Patnaik, Dipak Misra, SJ Mukhopadhaya and I...

SC keeps Subrata Roy jailed, slams abusive litigants wasting ‘hundreds of judge hours’, calls for frivolous lit curb

The Supreme Court ruled that Sahara boss Subrata Roy should stay in jail in a 207-page order, while noting in a post script to the judgment that Roy and Sahara had abused the judicial process and wasted “hundreds of judge hours”. Justices KS Radhakrishnan and Jagdish Singh Khehar ruled dismissed Roy...