Elite Indian Law Institute's director probed by Delhi HC about NUJS, KLA teaching record

The Delhi high court directed Indian Law Institute (ILI) Delhi to reconsider the eligibility of its officiating director Dr S Sivakumar for the post, after it was alleged that he had fudged facts about his qualification at the time of applying for the post of research professor at the institute in 2005.

Sivakumar had represented that he had 10 years of combined post-graduate (PG) teaching experience at NUJS Kolkata and Kerala Law Academy, however both the institutes had furnished RTI replies to lawyer Jose Meleth stating that he had taught only LLB courses there. Meleth filed a public interest litigation in the Delhi high court challenging Sivakumar’s appointment.

ILI defended the appointment saying that 10 years of PG teaching experience was not sacrosanct and that the director has vast research experience making him suitable for the job. However the bench of justices SK Kaul and Vipin Sanghi directed ILI’s executive council to reconsider his eligibility since he relied on false information to stake claim to a post in the institute first in 2005.

The court fixed 30 November for the next hearing.

ILI’s ex-officio president is the Chief Justice of India while the Attorney General of India and the law minister are its vice-presidents. [TOI]

Comments

Anand P. Mishra 26 Sept 2012, 05:04
+5 -0
Bad news for Indian legal education..Tragic that a premier legal research institution like Indian Law Institute is not able to find a duly qualified full-time Director and its managing with an Officiating or Incharge Director for over three and a half years...Despite having a large pool of celebrated and experienced law professors across the country, I wonder why this premier institution has to manage with a comparatively younger director in-charge whose qualification for the post itself is being questioned..ILI had the privilege to have the most renowned legal scholars and professors of the country to be its directors..Starting with its first director, Prof. LR Siva Subramanian, an ex-professor and dean of University of Delhi - Faculty of Law it is headed by stalwarts like Prof. KN Chandrashekharan Pillai, MP Singh, SK Verma and others from Delhi Law Faculty..It is a high time ILI gets a renowned legal scholar as a full-time director...I can't imagine such a thing happening with an IIT or a premier medical school!
Anonymous 26 Sept 2012, 12:27
+3 -0
It is not always ... er ... it seldom is a matter of merit in academic appointments. And if rumors are any indication, sometimes 'regionalism' can play an important role.
Ayush 26 Sept 2012, 16:10
+9 -0
I had an opportunity to interact with him last month. Certainly he has no clue as to what Law and English language are all about