Results: Maha Goa Bar Council gets ex-law firmite and youngest member ever

Bombay High Court
Bombay High Court

Twenty-seven-year-old Mumbai advocate and ex-Amarchand Mangaldas, Udwadia Udeshi and Wadia Ghandy lawyer Karan Bhosale has been elected into the Maharashtra & Goa Bar Council alongside 24 other advocates, while sole law firm candidate Hitesh Jain lost the election by 19 places.

The Maharashtra & Goa Bar Council announced the 25 winners late last week after months of protracted counting and legal challenges.

Nagpur candidate Aniruddha Krishnarao Choube, Solapur-based Milind Shivshankar Thobde, Aurangabad’s Vasant Digamberrao Salunke and Pune advocate Harshad Vasantrao Nimbalkar won the most numbers of votes respectively (see full list below).

Karan Bhosale, who is his family’s third successive generation on the Maharashtra & Goa Bar Council following his father and grandfather, ended up in 12th place winning a total of 1,306 votes running on a ticket of representing junior lawyers, improving welfare and legal education.

Bhosale told Legally India: “The reason I contested the election was mainly for the junior lawyers because the trend of the Bar Council is that junior lawyers are not represented adequately. In fact, the Bar Council rules provide that out of 25 seats a maximum of 10 seats can be made available to junior lawyers [of less than 10 years experience].”

“Unfortunately, in the last so many years there have been only two people who have made it through, one of them being my dad in his first election,” he added. “I thought why not give it a shot.”

Bhosale explained that he had campaigned across 10 districts in Maharashtra, had visited around 60-odd Bar Associations and delivered countless speeches either in Marathi or English. In his campaign he focused on pushing through the proposal of increasing the welfare fund to which advocates are eligible after 30 years of practice, to Rs 3 lakhs and promising to lobby for it to get increased to Rs 5 lakhs.

He said that he also hoped to increase the connection between Bar Council members in Mumbai and the rest of the state, particularly by using information technology and making computers available to regional Bar Associations.

“In most of the places the computers are just lying dormant,” he noted. “Once the IT mechanism kicks in it’ll act as fantastic link between the Bar Council and lawyers in the interior of state.”

Bhosale had worked for one year at Amarchand, interned for half a year at Udwadia and two years at Wadia Ghandy before completing an LLM at Columbia University in New York, returning to Mumbai in 2009 to practice as an advocate in the chambers of Maharashtra & Goa advocate general Ravi Kadam.

Bhosale said that therefore improving legal education was very important to him and he wanted to find ways for the local Bar Councils to assist on bettering legal education across the country.

However, he said that he did not think it was feasible for Bar Councils to effectively exert pressure on senior advocates to mandate a minimum wage for junior lawyers, noting that educating young lawyers of the options available to them would also open choices to them, such as joining litigation departments of law firms where the pay was better.

He and several sources said that it was believed that Bhosale was the youngest-ever Maharashtra & Goa Bar Council member.

ALMT partner Hitesh Jain, who was the only contesting candidate from a large law firm, won 534 aggregate votes after elimination of other candidates, but finished in 44th place.

He said: “I fell short but at the same time I have satisfaction in the entire process. I wanted to run very clean campaign and did not want to break any rules in the game. And secondly, the motive was to create awareness of the Bar Council of the new generation of lawyers in law firms. A large numbers of partners, associates and senior counsel from the original side came down to vote this time and there was certainly a satisfaction in the campaign this time.”

He added that he would continue to participate in the Bar Council in whatever way possible and would definitely run again next time.

Maharasthra & Goa Bar Council returning officer Varsha Rokade said: “I believe it went very well. In spite of the fact that the Supreme Court decision [questioning the voting mechanism] had come just one day before the election was held, we still managed to communicate it throughout. So all in all I believe it was a well organized and well-held election.”

The first meeting of the new Bar Council is understood to be scheduled for late June.

Full list of elected members Bar Council Maharashtra & Goa 2010: 1. Aniruddha Krishnarao Choube (Nagpur) 2. Milind Shivshankar Thobde (Solapur) 3. Vasant Digamberrao Salunke (Aurangabad) 4. Harshad Vasantrao Nimbalkar (Pune) 5. Anil Chandrabali Singh (Mumbai) 6. Uday Prakash Warunjikar (Mumbai) 7. Sureshchandra Ramrao Bhosale (Mumbai) 8. Avinash Bhaskarrao Avhad (Pune) 9. Pramod Pandurang Patil (Thane) 10. Ashish Panjabrao Deshmukh (Yavatmal) 11. Shivajirao Bhausaheb Chavan (Kolhapur) 12. Karan Dilip Bhosale (Mumbai) 13. Vitthal Bhaurao Kondedeshmukh (Mumbai) 14. Babusingh Kartarsingh Gandhi (Akola) 15. Balwant Harishchandra Jadhav (Latur) 16. Vipinkumar Leeladhar Bendale (Jalgaon) 17. Satish Abarao Deshmukh (Hingoli) 18. Ahmedkhan Usmankhan Pathan (Pune) 19. Avinash Janardan Bhide (Nashik) 20. Jayant Dattatray Jaibhave (Nashik) 21. Motisingh Ghanshyamdas Mohta (Akola) 22. Ashok Vitthal Patil (Ahmednagar) 23. Anil Mahadeorao Gowardipe (Nagpur) 24. Asif Shaukat Qureshi (Nagpur) 25. Nitin Laxman Chaudhari (Dhule)

Comments

Anonymous guest 21 May 2010, 13:55
+1 -1
So what is this dude's position on foreign firms? Is he any different from the old fogeys in that respect?
kianganz 21 May 2010, 21:37
+1 -0
I have just confirmed with him and he says that in principle, he is in favour of the entry of foreign law firms but only in phases inititially.
Anonymous guest 22 May 2010, 02:13
+2 -0
"Karan Bhosale, who is his family's third successive generation on the Maharashtra & Goa Bar Council..."
And then they question national law school pass-outs joining the corporate sector instead of litigation. If families rule, what else can one do?
Anonymous guest 22 May 2010, 02:44
+2 -0
Avinash, congratulations! This is great news. Keep it up.
Anonymous guest 22 May 2010, 04:33
+1 -1
Congratulations Karan! Splendid performance!

@3
Sorry if you are depressed about joining the corporate sector... You need to get your facts right.. I think you have misunderstood litigation and Bar Council to be one and the same thing.. Its also a pity that you construed this article and endeavor so pessimistically
Anonymous guest 22 May 2010, 06:02
+0 -0
We are really glad to have an promising youth represent us at the Bar Council. Keep it up!!!
Anonymous guest 22 May 2010, 06:52
+2 -0
i agree with person at 5, it is a shame that such a prestigious web site where all law students look up for aspirations, worship someone who himself says, " why not cos my father got through in his first year." sadly it is the ruling trend in litigation, it has become a family business, if i m not wrong the dude s dad is a judge now of the HC so obviously and as far as taking care of young lawyers is concerned, rather have some-one who has to fight his way thru, and understands the difficulties and not a person born into one. I would hail mr. Hitesh Jain in that respect, cos if someone has time to roam 10 districts and 60 places to deliver speeches, says a lot bout the future aims, more political than legal. I hope the bombay bar doesnt go the SCBA way, as it has traditionally been one of the most efficient and prestigious bar in the country. and people getting their way through by virtue of their family name is a disgrace.
Anonymous guest 22 May 2010, 09:56
+0 -0
totally agree with #3 and #6.

licence raj at its worst.
Anonymous guest 22 May 2010, 17:56
+0 -0
I dont agree with the family business at all. I knw of some candidates whose fathers were then current judges of the High court or the subordinates courts stood for elections but however their children never made their way through the Bar.

As far as this youngster Karan is concerned, he visited our small bar at Satara twice and I have myself heard him giving speeches in the open Bar. Also as per my personal information Karan visited the smallest taluka place and delivered speeches in Marathi. And moreover there shud be some educated youth representative in the Bar.

And also writer 3, 6 if your theory about known family business was right then in that case many other candidates who did not get elected this time should have got elected.

CONGRATULATIONS KARAN !! KEEP IT UP !!
Anonymous guest 22 May 2010, 18:16
+0 -0
Keep it up KARAN...Finally there is a worthy young representative who is member for his own efforts and not for anything other reason whatsoever..!!!!
Have become a fan of your speech Karan !!!
All youngster should walk on your foot steps..
Anonymous guest 22 May 2010, 20:06
+1 -0
wow #9 if good speeches is what it takes to be a youth represenatative in bar council then we should teach only public speaking, mooting in law school and then definitely, as lawyers we are acting like sheep waiting for someone to tend to us all the time, lets hope this guy is not another flash in the pan, and actually does something, for the youth other than making it a family business. I sense a politician in the making! impressive degrees. but lack of stability in a place. still still...lets see! let the work speak for him and lets not judge him yet!!
Anonymous guest 23 May 2010, 05:47
+0 -0
I don't understand why people can't appreciate and take his victory in the positive way.. He deserved and hence won..

Let his actions speak for himself in the future..

Congratulations Karan!
Anonymous guest 23 May 2010, 16:19
+0 -0
@12

I Agree with @12 (Aditi)... It seems that this is the third Jr. Advocate who has made it to the Bar Council of Mah. & Goa so far..

I have gone through the above article.. The anonymous commentators herein above have painted this to be a family business etc.. Come on guys.. Is that all you read this guy stood for?? Well lets refresh our memories, so I am quoting from the above:

"Bhosale told Legally India: "The reason I contested the election was mainly for the junior lawyers because the trend of the Bar Council is that junior lawyers are not represented adequately."

"....ended up in 12th place winning a total of 1,306 votes running on a ticket of representing junior lawyers, improving welfare and legal education."

"He said that he also hoped to increase the connection between Bar Council members in Mumbai and the rest of the state, particularly by using information technology and making computers available to regional Bar Associations."

"Bhosale said that therefore improving legal education was very important to him and he wanted to find ways for the local Bar Councils to assist on bettering legal education across the country."


So what if he has someone in his family who has been there already... Are we going to forbid all such people who follow their family's footsteps...? And sorry to break it to you, but if you think that the so called family business is not prevalent in other arenas (including the legal corporate world) then you need to look around... What I think one needs to see is merit as well...

This fellow has made it so far.. He seems to have his agendas, and I think we should give him a chance!
Anonymous guest 24 May 2010, 00:05
+0 -0
I wish to extend to Karan my warmest congratulations on his election as a member of Bar councial,
his election comes at an important juncture when there all over is mess in council.
It is my pleasure to express to him, my sincere congratulations on the occasion of his winning the Election.
The committment and sincerity of karan cannot be ignored, whatever he has achieved at this age is
only his hard work. he is scholar that he has proved but now he has proved that he is good
teamleader also, i have heard the speech given by him for election, there was really something to beleive on his statements, and first time i felt that this new young lawyer really can do for welfare of young advocates, everybody knows what is the postion of lawyers currently, and hope and expect from persons like karan to focus on main points which are ignored and really want someone to look into.I take this opportunity to praise his
permanent commitment towards junior lawyers for their interests
I wish him a successful and eventful tenure as Member of Bar council
with many more laurels in his career in the future.



ASHWIN HAWELIKAR
Anonymous guest 6 Jun 2010, 02:07
+0 -0
To criticise is a rights of an Advocate. To criticise you don't need to know the person. To criticise, is very simple, you can do it without knowing the merit. Many of us i.e. We advocates tend to give our opinions/judgements without examining the merits thouroghly. Instead of criticising; why can't we give a chance to young advocates to work for legal fraternity and prove their merit. Let him prove his point. May be he can give you new ideas and programmes which we never thought of in our busy litigating and NON LITIGATING schedules. It is too early to pass general comments without giving fair chance and causing unnecessary comments like FAMILY BUSINESS. I detaste such comment as it is made on the basis of what they read in Newspapers or what they heard from his Opponents. I sincerely hope that Karan will prove his promise as Young Advocate to legal fraternity. I wish him GOOD LUCK and congratulate for his SUCCESS.
RAJIV PATIL.
Anonymous guest 11 Aug 2010, 07:13
+0 -0
Ashwin, I think you also voted first preference for Karan instead of Bhushan.
amit patil, mayur shanbaug and you all are good friends of bhushan, who is more deserving person than any other candidates