Case of the week: Dude asks Indian court to ban US Gandhi-Bot Beer (which is probably not even sold here)

A consumer activist Thursday filed a complaint against America’s New England Brewing Company, which sparked a controversy by using a picture of Mahatma Gandhi on its beer cans and selling them in certain parts of India.

Consumer Guidance Society of India media cell chief Viveck Shettyy lodged the complaint before the Metropolitan Magistrate of 66th Court in Andheri, invoking relevant sections of the Indian Penal Code.

“Gandhi ji is father of our nation and we all hold him in great respect. I am deeply shocked and outraged by the use of his picture on beer cans of ‘Gandhi-Bot’ sold in our country,” Shettyy told IANS

He said it was particularly insulting as Gandhi had abstained from alcohol all his life and even advocated prohibition. The beer company’s action was a mockery of his principles and values of life, he added.

“It is all the more ironic that while (US) President Barack Obama has been deeply inspired by Gandhi ji as he has repeatedly said in his speeches, an American brewery should stoop to such unethical levels for brand promotions and sales,” Shettyy said.

In the market for nearly five years, the Gandhi-Bot beer has been promoted as fully vegetarian and the company last week announced that it would rename the product.

Referring to apology tendered by the company recently to those who found it “insensitive”, Shettyy claimed it serves no purpose and he would appeal to the court to impose a ban on the beer.

Shettyy also questioned the concerned authorities which gave permission for the product which has defamed Gandhi.

In response to a question by Legally India on Twitter whether the beer was even for sale in India, lawyers tweeted:

@gauthamgururaj: @LegallyIndia Alcohol import is super painful. And has a whole lot of labeling requirements. No way, anything with Gandhi will be cleared!!

@kumarsaurabhnet: @LegallyIndia don’t think it is. If it was, it would be violative of some national emblem act. As the Mont Blanc Gandhi pen was, resulting in at least one law suit in India by some enterprising, but easily offended lawyer.

Comments

Scooter- 30 Jan 2015, 00:22
+5 -2
People are really out of work to get offended by everything under the sun!

Dring beer- make peace..hence gandhi. big shit.
independence 30 Jan 2015, 03:23
+1 -1
Am sure most of US would not like an Abe Lincoln or Mandela or whatever beer as well. Besides legal issues.
Let us be a bit more confident and not confuse being liberal with being apologetic for any suggestion to moderate life.
Guest 30 Jan 2015, 10:08
+1 -1
I'm fairly certain the US wouldn't have a problem with Mandela beer, given that he's South African.

What legal issues?

As long as the beer isn't being binge-drunk, i don't see how this is not moderate behaviour.
independence 30 Jan 2015, 11:17
+1 -0
Would South Africa have a problem with Mandela beer? Or [bad example but just to prove a point] Italy with Pope beer? Let us go further.. Mother Teresa whiskey? No? Think about it. Even Vijaybeta had the sense to name his beer after a little birdie and no more.