GNLU admin leaps in to help students out of detention limbo after retrospective rule change

GNLU helps out students caught in a lurch
GNLU helps out students caught in a lurch

GNLU Gandhinagar has cleared the exam applications of two detained students yesterday, minutes after /Legally India/ reported yesterday that the students were in detention limbo due to administrative inaction for weeks.

Until yesterday, the two students stood to lose a year due to alleged administrative inaction following a retroactive rule change. The students were detained in the third year of BALLB for the second consecutive year in August 2016, despite the existence of a university regulation at the time they had failed their exam enabling them to potentially be promoted this year. However, the rules were changed in February 2016 that retakes would only be allowed after two instead one year of detention.

GNLU’s academic council had allegedly been sitting on their application to take the repeat exam since July. We reported on the inaction yesterday evening after having requested a comment from GNLU director Bimal Patel yesterday morning.

Less than a hour after publication of the story, the students received the following message from the registrar:

[…] As approved by the Academic Council and in view of the amendment in the regulation 27 (b) (vi), you are being offered a repeat exam of 100 marks in the relevant papers. The schedule of this repeat exam is available on the university website. […]

It is understood that the exam will be held between 15 and 18 September, according to GNLU’s website.

Comments

GNLU community 9 Sept 2016, 19:22
+1 -8
Big slap to Legally India. This shows that GNLU administration is very prompt. Legally India only speaks for bad students and oversmart students.

Professor Patel is the best VC in India. Sir has made world-class improvement to infra and faculty because he is a world-class person. Sir was eminent jurist at the Hague and have two PhD: one from world-famous Lieden University and one from Seedling School, Jaipur under great Professor VS Mani. No VC can boast such qualification.

Writing on the wall: PROFESSOR PATEL STAND TALL.

We are with you Sir!

- on behalf of GNLU community
kianganz 10 Sept 2016, 06:07
+5 -0
How can you slap? Please please no more slaps to us in every GNLU article comment, it hurts too much only! :)
Delhi lawyer 12 Sept 2016, 06:04
+2 -0
This isn't about naming and shaming GNLU and the previous report doesn't hurt the image of GNLU. I don't think poor administrative decisions are a reflection on the institution or its students - we all know how the administration can suck in most institutions. I think such Legally India articles actually help the people in trouble. Coverage of bad administrative decisions by the media are a "slap" to the administration, who sometimes wake-up feeling the sting. Hence the saying, pen is mightier than sword.

Personally, good job Kian and Prachi. You guys are often a great help in covering stories that really needs the "help" of the Fourth Estate. I feel really happy to see such journalism. Counting on you guys to keep up the good work.
Baba Sehgal 12 Sept 2016, 09:23
+1 -0
"Writing on the wall, Professor Patel stand tall".

Haha hahaha haha. Do we have Baba Sehgal in the house?
Alumnus2cents 13 Sept 2016, 09:32
+0 -0
Bhai sab theek hai? Sir ko mera salaam.

Before speaking for the community at large, you should understand that there is a reason people have a difference of opinion. And that each individual only wants the university to progress and improve.

Once you develop this understanding you'll recognise that most people raise their voices to see improvements and this is possible through a meaningful, consistent and proper dialogue. When the possibility of that is shut down and doesn't exist, people then resort to expressing their annoyance through other means.

The University's alumni association, is not run by the alumni. College committees aren't run by the students independently. There is no student union. These are fundamental flaws that need correction and the students need to be empowered to be able to take and make decisions affecting them and their lives at the university.

We have been saying these things for years but I think the recognition needs to come from the top. The University should stop viewing everyone who speaks out and demands answers as truant and instead should really step up and embrace open processes.
Bakeel Saab 15 Sept 2016, 11:33
+1 -0
Is that you Bimal Patel?
Alumn 10 Sept 2016, 06:00
+0 -0
LI think such decision can come in some minutes haaaa. after their reporting .....As a procedure, in general for any board meeting ... Agenda preparation, sending to members who may be in different parts of country, calling meeting, deliberation, decision.... ...looking to the members of committee on gnlu website ...for LI only this possible in few minutes...
Take true spirit
kianganz 10 Sept 2016, 06:06
+2 -0
In a few minutes, no, that's ridiculous. But after inaction for months, we reach out for comment to director in the morning and by evening they take a call to allow retakes, seems within the realm of causation...
Friend of affected 10 Sept 2016, 16:07
+4 -0
I am a batchmate of the students affected in this case. It is irrefutable to say that the admin of GNLU follows no procedure whatsoever. Any request or clarification is met with a response to either come back the next day or that a committee will decide on the issue.

In regard to this specific incident, the affected have been trying to get a solution from the admin since June. Both the examination department members and the registrar of academic affairs cited the rule change which was unknownst to them until that point. For perspective, all rules framed and amended by the admin of GNLU is done by them in a dark cave in secrecy while on peyote and is notified by the ICT department that pays more attention to busting students watching porn rather than making sure that the official website works properly and is updated.

Until a few days ago the affected students had pretty much accepted as fate that they had lost another year to the arbitrariness of the gnlu admin. So unless Jesse Custer (Preacher reference) himself spoke to the admin, the promptness of the admin can only be attributed to them wanting to maintain their reputation (what reputation lol). Hence, bravo and thanks to legally india for saving the day.
XX 10 Sept 2016, 15:59
+0 -0
Kian can you give us some updates on Bimal Patel's South Indian version occupying the VC chair at NUJS? Is his term being renewed?
Guest 11 Sept 2016, 09:11
+0 -0
Kian it is good you are doing such stories, but you only sporadically attack a few NLUs. You need to do a comprehensive report on the corruption and nepotism at all NLUs. The easiest thing you can do is focus on is the poor state of faculty. You can simply visit the websites of the NLUs and look at the faculty list (cross-check with the students if necessary). You can also ask law firm partners if they are happy with the quality of training students receive.
Delhi lawyer 12 Sept 2016, 06:06
+1 -0
People need to reach out to Kian and Prachi for help and give them the necessary information. How will they report a story without the information?
I don't think they will ever refuse to report story of unfair administration at any lawschool. They are pretty helpful when the cause is just.
Waah Waah 11 Sept 2016, 16:57
+0 -0
Poor guys are being allowed to write the exam when the semester is about to end.
Ishhh 11 Sept 2016, 17:28
+0 -0
He is trying his very best to get it renewed. Despite the numerous controversies that happened during his tenure, he may even get it. The next EC meeting should put all doubts to rest, God rest NUJS' soul.
Guest 12 Sept 2016, 19:54
+0 -0
Death of NUJS if Bhat gets an extension. Kian can you get some gossip through your contacts in the NUJS executive council?
Ishhh 14 Sept 2016, 03:23
+0 -0
All Kian needs to do is ask ;)
kianganz 14 Sept 2016, 09:55
+0 -0
I'm asking! :)
Ishhh 16 Sept 2016, 05:31
+0 -0
EC meeting this month end. Gonna be a close call. VC is doing all the lobbying he can for renewal. Some members don't want him for obvious reasons, but the more influential ones (including ex and sitting judges) may lean towards him.
Guest 13 Sept 2016, 16:36
+1 -0
Hey Kian any updates on how NLS is affected by the riots in Bangalore?