Man dies crashing into Harish Salve's Bentley [CORRECTION: but no one is suing anyone]

The brother of a man who died when his car allegedly slammed into senior advocate Harish Salve’s Bentley, driven by his chauffeur, told the DNA that the family was cosidering filing a case against Salve and his driver for “rash driving” [see correction below].

Salve told DNA that on his advice, his driver had filed a case of “rash and negligent” driving against the man on the day of the accident but later withdrew the FIR, with Salve extending his sympathies to the family of the man who died in hospital on the day of the accident on 2 May. [DNA]

Update: DNA seems to have removed the story from its website shortly after we first published it. We’re trying to find out why so we can update or amend the story if required.

Update 2: DNA has issued a correction on its website, stating: “In today’s (14/05/2014) dna we carried a news report, Bentley mishap: Family mulls plaint against Salve, which said the family of the driver who died from injuries of an accident earlier this month is considering a case against Mr Harish Salve. The report is not true. We regret the inconvenience caused to both to Mr Salve and the family of the deceased.”

Comments

Harbinger of Justice 14 May 2014, 07:01
+2 -1
It is very strange that none of the bigger newspapers are reporting this piece. Also the DNA report which is the source of this article is not working anymore. [...]
kianganz 14 May 2014, 07:34
+2 -1
It is quite strange that the original report has disappeared...

Here's a cached copy of the link:
http://cc.bingj.com/cache.aspx?q=site%3awww.dnaindia.com+harish+salve+bentley&d=1380254231015&mkt=en-IN&setlang=en-US&w=DAu2i9mgyhe0V4pxo66ik-owFC-dgAWD

Not sure if Salve would have asked for a takedown - it's not really a very critical story. It could be that the family got cold feet when they suddenly saw it in print? Strange...
Harbinger of Justice 14 May 2014, 08:46
+3 -2
I don't understand why my comment was moderated especially when I am not even making any allegations. I was just asking questions which are really important to understand in this case.
kianganz 14 May 2014, 09:56
+2 -1
The facts are not really clear right now, in light of DNA having unpublished its story, and your comment basically read like pure speculation without anything relating to the specifics of this case.
Harbinger of Justice 14 May 2014, 10:23
+3 -1
I never stated them as facts, I also merely state that these are questions which need answers.
Alas... 14 May 2014, 09:06
+0 -0
Kian, how the news related to death of a person in an accident involving Mr. Salve (who is the most famous torch bearer of justice) be a story in first place, let alone a very critical story in your words? Would your assessment have been same, God forbid, if the deceased was someone from your family?
kianganz 14 May 2014, 09:59
+2 -0
This story is obviously very tragic and sad, but it doesn't seem as though either Mr Salve or his driver are to blame at all, at least from what's been published (notwithstanding DNA now having taken it down).

I'm sure that police can reconstruct how the accident has happened and who was to blame, from the wreckage, etc.

Not sure what's really going on right now though, to be honest...
Harbinger of Justice 14 May 2014, 09:35
+1 -1
With the hope that this time my comment will not be edited.

Was the accident of the Wagon R with Mr. Salve's 2 seater Bentley? I understand that the driver usually did not drive the 2 seater Bentley and it is common knowledge that Mr. Salve used, and liked, to drive his Bentley every morning from his house to the office. So was Mr. Salve driving the Bentley when the accident happened?

Kian, it would be great if you could actually check the veracity of facts independently before copying articles from news websites and just pasting them on your website.
wut 22 Sept 2017, 18:18
+0 -0
Since when did Bentley start manufacturing two-seaters?
Reality 14 May 2014, 07:28
+2 -3
Motorcyclists do not follow any traffic or safety rules, they change lanes randomly and without indicator, they zip at speeds well above the speed limit, they carry things on their arm (like helmet) and on the bike handle (like grocery bag), they do not use rear view mirror, and they do not appreciate that bikes are about being careful and restrained. Its sad that a biker died, but there are lots of rash bikers who cause inconvenience, traffic jams and accidents.
kianganz 14 May 2014, 07:28
+2 -0
I think it wasn't a biker but a Wagon R that crashed into Salve's Bentley...
Salvage 14 May 2014, 08:26
+2 -0
Quite surprised that the mainstream media has not reported this at all.
DBS 14 May 2014, 09:30
+2 -0
Not to worry, Mr. Salve has a Range Rover & some other cars too!! And anyways it is vacation time.
kianganz 14 May 2014, 10:11
+0 -0
DNA has issued a correction:

[quote]In today's (14/05/2014) dna we carried a news report, Bentley mishap: Family mulls plaint against Salve, which said the family of the driver who died from injuries of an accident earlier this month is considering a case against Mr Harish Salve. The report is not true. We regret the inconvenience caused to both to Mr Salve and the family of the deceased.[/quote]

However, the accident did happen apparently - I understand that the correction merely concerns the threat of legal action, and I'm not entirely sure why it was misreported by DNA, if at all.
Harbinger of Justice 14 May 2014, 10:21
+0 -0
How is the story not true? The clarification itself is very vague. So are they saying that Naresh (Joginder's brother who they claim to have spoken to) was lying or were they lying about having spoken to Naresh.
Nonsense 14 May 2014, 10:25
+0 -2
Dont you hate it when news reporters write "plaint" when they should write complaint or suit...
Ameer Chand AtoZ 14 May 2014, 10:37
+7 -0
Haha..ha..ha... who has decided that it was the deceased who actually 'crashed into' the bigger car and not the other way round? LoLs!
kianganz 14 May 2014, 15:59
+0 -1
Something here seems to confirm at least part of the story - the Deccan Herald had published something on 2 May, the day of the accident, before the man had died:
http://www.deccanherald.com/content/403978/harish-salve039s-car-involved-mishap.html

---quote---
[quote]According to Salve, the other car, a WagonR, struck a road divider before hitting into the Bentley in which he was being driven from home at about 7.30 am. Senior police officers said they would be able to say who was at fault only after investigations. However, an FIR was registered against Joginder based on the complaint filed by Salve’s driver Arvind Pande. “Arvind Pande has filed an FIR against Joginder, the driver of WagonR. Action will be taken after investigation and based on evidence,” said Mukesh Kumar Meena, Joint Commissioner of Police (New Delhi Region) [...]

Salve said he was going through a file when he felt the impact of the crash. Joginder’s vehicle hit a divider before crashing into the front wheel of his Bentley, and then spinning twice or thrice on the road.

“I am shaken up. Had the car hit the middle of my vehicle, I wouldn't be speaking to you on the phone right now,” he told Deccan Herald.

Salve said he would ask his driver not to pursue the case against Joginder.[/quote]
---end quote---
Well done LI 19 May 2014, 13:03
+5 -0
Kian, you should be congratulated for having b*#ls of steel. When the rest of the media has kept this entire episode quiet, you display it proudly. The media masters are clearly scared of those who are in the corridors of power. The similarities of this case with that of the 'Ambani Aston Martin' is uncanny.
Anon 20 May 2014, 04:38
+1 -2
What's the big deal about Salve withdrawing the complaint? Can a criminal complaint survive when the accused has died?
Seema Sapra 22 May 2014, 15:17
+4 -0
The undisputed facts are that a man died in a car accident involving two cars - A wagon R (driven by the man who died) and a Bentley (owned by Harish Salve).

A man died in a motor accident - does the law not require a police investigation into culpability after registration of an FIR? The investigation might conclude that the accident was caused by the deceased or it might conclude that the Bentley driver was culpable in causing death due to rash or negligent driving.

But is an FIR not the necessary first step that must precede a full police investigation?
crux 25 May 2014, 08:39
+3 -0
Yes! this is really the question. Do we have rule of law or not?

Second, whether DNA received a legal notice or something which made them take down the report?