RamJet argues for Chautala, Delhi HC doesn't bite, tells ex-CM to surrender tomorrow

The Delhi high court has directed former Haryana chief minister Om Prakash Chautala to surrender to Tihar Jail authorities here Saturday and discontinue his political rallies effective Friday.

Justice Siddharth Mridul, in an order, also asked the jail authorities to take Chautala to the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) here, if they consider it necessary, as he complains he has fractured his leg.

Chautala, who is also the Indian National Lok Dal chief, appeared before the court Friday after it Thursday sought his personal appearance as the Central Bureau of Investigation sought cancellation of his bail and bringing forward his surrender date, which was earlier fixed for Oct 17.

“I am pained and disappointed with Chautala’s act. Now that he is discharged from hospital, he should surrender,” the judge remarked on the conduct on Chautala, who was granted bail on medical grounds, but has been actively holding rallies to campaign for the Oct 15 assembly elections in Haryana.

Senior lawyers Ram Jethmalani and Hariharan represented Chautala in a packed court room with Chautala’s supporters, journalists, and lawyers.

Jethmalani, advancing his arguments in support of Chautala, insisted that he be permitted to surrender on Oct 17 but the court refused.

Defending the act of Chautala of holding political rallies, he said that “he was just performing his constitutional duty towards the people and there is nothing wrong in it”.

During the hearing, Chautala also personally urged the judge to let him surrender Oct 17.

But the court decided not to bargain over the surrender date, because of Chautala’s conduct. It said that it has been “very sympathetic” to Chautala because “he is an elderly gentleman and he is suffering from various ailments”.

He was first granted interim bail May 21, 2013, and has been getting extension of bail on the ground that he was admitted in the intensive care unit (ICU) of Medanta Hospital in Gurgaon due to poor health. The hospital, however, discharged him recently and since then Chautala has been campaigning.

“If he is well enough to travel, well enough to address rallies, then he is well enough to surrender,” the court said.

CBI counsel Rajdeepa Behura asked the court to direct Chautala to surrender immediately as he had abused the process of law. “The interim bail was granted for medical issues, not to hold public rallies,” Behura told court.

Chautala has been out on bail after being sentenced to 10 years in prison in the teachers’ recruitment scam case. On Sep 26, the high court cancelled the interim bail granted to Chautala on medical ground and asked him to surrender Oct 17.

A special CBI court here Jan 22, 2013 sentenced Chautala, his son Ajay Chautala and eight others to 10 years in jail, one convict to five years in jail, while 45 others were each handed out four-year jail terms after finding them guilty of illegally recruiting 3,206 junior basic trained teachers in Haryana in 2000 when Om Prakash Chautala was the chief minister.

Comments

Guest 11 Oct 2014, 04:35
+4 -3
it is remarkable that the venerable 90 plus Ram Jethmalani stands for 90 minutes and argues the important cases with undiminished elan. Hats off to him!The judges and lawyers would benefit from his sharp legal acumen and he should be respected for his expertise as much as for his age. It is a pity he might get turned down at times because of the clients on whose behalf this legend comes up before the courts. We will never see the likes of him for another 100 years. The other top living legend justice V.K. Krishna Iyer does not and cannot practice having served on the bench of the apex court.

Dr. Ravindran Pranatharthy
Advocate
Glory Days 11 Oct 2014, 09:59
+2 -7
I do not recall a single 'significant' matter in the past few years, where our old legend may have delivered a thumping order for his client/s... just like Sachin did not deliver a single "against-all-odds" performance a la Sharjah Cup in the last decade-odd of his career.

Hang up your boots, dear sir... let us recall you for your successes and not such failures.

Bruce Springsteen, Glory Days:

Think I'm going down to the well tonight and I'm gonna drink till I get my fill
And I hope when I get old I don't sit around thinking about it, but I probably will
Yeah just sitting back trying to recapture a little of the glory of
Well but time slips away and leaves you with nothing mister but boring stories of
Glory days
Points to Ponder 11 Oct 2014, 11:29
+1 -0
As was eloquently put in an article, he is the 'first resort for the last resort'. That would put things into perspective!
Legally Blah 11 Oct 2014, 21:21
+4 -0
Do you even follow news? Who was the arguing advocate in the Murugan matter which has been one of the leading cases decided this year.