Bar, Bench & Litigation

Give up your copyright, Penguin-Chicken! Lawrence Liang, readers serve legal notice on Doniger publisher

Penguin Chicken
Penguin Chicken
Advocate Lawrence Liang, part of the Bangalore-based Alternative Law Forum, has issued a legal notice to Penguin India, claiming that the publisher has violated freedom of speech laws and readers’ rights by agreeing to destroy all copies of Wendy Doniger’s book The Hindus.

Swatanter Kumar PIL adjourned: Ex-judge claims ‘malicious conspiracy’ - X says feared personal safety, told family, friends, teacher

Swatanter Kumar
Swatanter Kumar
The Supreme Court has adjourned its hearing in the public interest litigation (PIL) against Swatanter Kumar until 26 March, as two more interveners attempted to join the PIL.

Penguin statement in full: ‘Intolerant’ laws, particularly 295A IPC, made us pulp Doniger’s book

Penguin India has released a statement, blaming section 295A of the Indian Penal Code, which bans “outraging the religious feelings of any class of citizens” with “malicious intent”.

Swatanter Kumar submits affidavit ahead of Intern X’s SC hearing tomorrow | Read X’s PIL

Supreme Court convenes tomorrow
Supreme Court convenes tomorrow
Legally India has obtained a copy of the public interest litigation filed by anonymous lawyer X, a former intern of ex-Supreme Court judge Swatanter Kumar, whose case will again get heard by the Supreme Court tomorrow (14 February).

Do you want to be an amicus? SC opens list to new ‘friends of the court’ (but won’t be exclusive)

Amicus
Amicus
The Supreme Court has opened up its panel of lawyers eligible to be selected as amicus curiae (Latin for “friend of the court”), to assist the judges from time to time in matters.

Bombay HC remains old man’s world with no women in batch of 11 new senior counsel for 2nd time running

The Bombay high court, hot on the heels of the Delhi high court that designated three new senior advocates, has named 11 advocates to become seniors, though none of them were women.

Madras HC chief RK Agrawal elevated to SC

Madras high court chief justice RK Agrawal was elevated to the Supreme Court yesterday, reported the PTI . His judicial career began in February 1999 at the Allahabad high court 14 years after which he was appointed acting chief justice of the Madras high court. He became chief justice of Madras HC ...

Doniger blames Indian laws as Penguin’s ‘banned’ book sales skyrocket | Join LI ed Kian Ganz in live chat on CNN-IBN website at 5pm

The media, in India and abroad, has predictably had a field day over the settlement Penguin India entered into to recall and destroy all India-based copies of Wendy Doniger’s book, The Hindus: An Alternative History , against which a religious organisation filed criminal and civil cases. The Mint ca...

Can Swatanter Kumar be removed from NGT because of intern’s written complaint, SG asked

The Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF) asked solicitor general Mohan Parasaran if National Green Tribunal (NGT) chairperson Swatanter Kumar can face removal proceedings based on treating the SC sexual harassment petition against him as “written complaint”, reported the Indian Express . An ex...

Penguin settles religious conservatives’ civil & criminal cases by pulping book of Hindu history

The Hindus
The Hindus
In settlement of a civil and two criminal suits brought by a religious group against Penguin Books India, the publisher has agreed to withdraw and destroy all copies of a history book on Hinduism.

Delhi chief justice NV Ramana elevated to Supreme Court

Delhi high court chief justice NV Ramana was elevated to the Supreme Court on Saturday and will assume office from Thursday, reported the New Indian Express . Ramana served as chief at the Andhra Pradesh high court from 10 March to 20 May last year, and was elevated as Delhi HC’s chief on 20 Septemb...

Bihar district judges face dismissal after allegedly being found with 'some women' in police raid

The Patna high court’s full court has recommended the dismissal of three district judges to the Bihar government for, allegedly, being “found with some women during a police raid” at a Nepal hotel on Republic Day, reported the Express . Nawada court sub-judge Komal Ram, Ara sessions judge Jitendra N...

SC Prasad J orders Rs 5 lakh costs for 'fanciful' allegations against himself made by ex-MLA

Supreme Court justices CK Prasad and Kurien Joseph dismissed, with costs of Rs 5 lakh, the review petition of ex-MLA Kishore Samrite in which Samrite had alleged impropriety against Prasad, reported the Times of India . Samrite had asserted that Prasad should have recused from the case in which Samr...

NLSIU gets second senior counsel in Dayan Krishnan, alongside Amit Sibal and Anup Bhambhani at Delhi HC

Amit Sibal
Amit Sibal
Amit Sibal, Cambridge University graduate, Dayan Krishnan, public prosecutor and 1993 NLSIU Bangalore graduate, and Anup Bhambhani, have been designated senior counsel in the Delhi high court.

Orissa, Madras lawyers on double hunger strike ‘unto death’ over bench, language, as Mumbai strikes ‘successful’

Hunger strike for permanent Western Orissa HC bench : Orissa high court lawyers launched an indefinite hunger strike today on the third day of their court boycott, to protest against the lack of a permanent bench of the HC in western Orissa. The lawyers have also asked all banks and financial establ...

SC judgment thunders against absent ‘fools' paradise’ AoR who sent ‘Arzi Farzi, half-baked proxy counsel’

BS Chauhan
BS Chauhan
An SC bench came down heavily on an advocate-on-record who did not turn up for a hearing and instead sent a nameless lawyer holding himself out as “proxy counsel”.

After RM Lodha scoffs at joining Lokpal panel, HL Dattu may get post

After the Supreme Court’s second-most senior judge and next Chief Justice of India (CJI) RM Lodha said he would be the last person to accept appointment to the Lokpal selection panel, Chief justice of India (CJI) P Sathasivam reportedly nominated the SC’s third-most senior judge HL Dattu to the pane...

Two sex harassment complaints made to Supreme Court’s new committee within a fortnight

The Supreme Court Gender Sensitisation and Internal Complaints Committee (GSICC) has received two complaints of sexual harassment since it was set up on 26 November 2013, reported the PTI , citing the GSICC Annual Report (PDF): In the First Meeting of the GSICC held on 9/12/2013, an Internal Sub-Com...

Delhi district judiciary remains empty as DJS examinees lose case, but infra insufficient anyway

Six Delhi Judicial Service (DJS) examinees from 2011 have lost the case for their instatement in the city’s lower judiciary, due to a lack of courtrooms and infrastructure, reported the PTI . The petitioners, who had secured a little over the cut-off ranks for appointment to the DJS, had argued that...

SC orders DJ report on Birbhum ‘kangaroo court’ gang rape, Sid Luthra to assist

A bench headed by Chief Justice of India (CJI) P Sathasivam ordered the Birbhum district judge to submit a detailed report about action taken by police in the West Bengal village ‘kangaroo court’-ordered gang rape case. The Supreme Court has appointed additional solicitor general Sidharth Luthra to ...