So… I was sent an email more than two months ago containing nothing but this attachment and a request to publish it. I apologise to the anonymous author for the delay. The post is a nice rant, pretty well-written and raises interesting points, although it’s a bit short in supporting evidence. So, here goes, please enjoy or not and leave your thoughts in the comments.

Most of us, throughout our lives, are led to believe that, success is the fruit of hard work, dedication, commitment, common sense, intelligence and what not!

I am sorry to say, that the real world does not function like that! Success depends on your daddy’s contacts, your daddy’s coercive powers and how can your daddy contribute to future business in a law firm. However, you’re lucky it does not end here, success also depends on the experience you have, the opportunities presented to you, which is highly unlikely to have as a fresh graduate.

So, it seems like most kids, across the country, are struggling between the devil and the deep sea. The former being those kids who have daddy’s big contacts and the latter being the ones who have been in the rat race for 3+ years!

Do not dishearten yourself just as yet; you have a third way out. You think you can develop relations with the people you intern with and you may just make it one day. Although, what is one supposed to do when the devil and the deep sea meet you there as well.

Somehow, I am led to believe that one’s CGPA, one’s participation in co-curricular and extra-curricular activities has absolutely no value as compared to those people who always knew that daddy would help them out in the end and they would have a high paying job and a comfortable lifestyle while obviously they partied their way through law school.

I am positive that many students feel this way, and sometimes I wish there was something that could be done about it. I hope that someday, this attitude changes.

Due recognition be given to those who deserve it, as they did struggle during exams, they did their share of moot activity and debates and what not! They are not just looking for a job with a leather seat, a wooden desk and an air-conditioned office space but genuinely are in search of a future, a career!

Comments

Adv. Vivek 25 Nov 2011, 04:21
+0 -0
A very nice article. It is absolutely true and correct to say that a good legal career depends much more contacts than on talent and intelligence. In litigation it is very much of Family Name and goodwill which works.
?? 25 Nov 2011, 07:24
+0 -0
believe i saw this earlier ... guess author posted himself / herself ....
grammar nazi 25 Nov 2011, 08:27
+0 -0
this post should be titled 'the attack of the manic commas'
Last_Day_Intern 25 Nov 2011, 11:02
+0 -0
I don't agree with the blanket argument that the author's making. While I agree that a lot of people whose dad/relatives have good contacts get jobs that they otherwise might not have deserved, I think if you work hard it won't really matter because chances are you're going to get that swanky job too. Here's why.

I think the only ones by and large affected by this "super-contact power" (let's call it that) are the ones in the middle. Who are just about average or above average and who could or could not get in based on luck/super-contact power.

Those who are at the top will recruited by law firms they aim at, or go do their BCL in Oxford or take up practice in courts they choose, and BECAUSE they're good, they will get what they want. I think if someone's claiming that they're really smart/hardworking/good and gaining employment is difficult for them, that's just a whole load of tosh. Either you aren't trying hard enough or you think your IQ is more than your ego.

The ones at the bottom are out of the race, of course with sufficient super contact power, they can get that job you slogged through 2 internships and 5 interview for too, but, how well they progress will remain to be seen. Besides, those are super minorities, and chances are, they probably don't stop you from getting a job (because let's not forget you're good at being a lawyer, if you weren't you wouldn't be getting out muscled anyway).

The middle ones are the ones most likely to get affected. But even then, considering all the opportunities out there, you should be able to get SOME job, maybe not the AMSS or AZB, but a Tatva or a Crestlaw kind of job is guaranteed, if you can't get those also, then: refer back to last para.

So let's face it. Nepotism exists no matter what, that's how life works, That's also how law school works (remember that faculty member who looooooved X or Y, and gave him/her a lot more marks then you for the same assignment of the same quality?), so can we please stop acting like little children and grow up?
Nice post but then? 25 Nov 2011, 18:43
+0 -0
I find it unfair that the post has been rated as 10 and at the same time there are other posts as well which are good but have been rated below what they deserve.
kianganz 25 Nov 2011, 19:37
+0 -0
Hi #5 - the ratings system is not perfect and I agree this post was not a 10. But someone must have really liked it and since there was only one vote of 10, that one stuck.

I would have given it a 6 or a 7, maybe (and have done so now, so the vote average is reduced). If you disagree with the score, just sign in with (or create a free) Legally India account and you can rate the post too.

Best,
Kian
Pritish 28 Nov 2011, 05:52
+0 -0
I completely agree with what the author has stated. This is a common phenomenon in the legal profession these days. I have experienced the discrimination myself. There have been times when I haven't been allowed to intern in a lot of law firms because I did not come from a legal background or my daddy was not from this profession. Hard work and sincerity is an alien concept these days. The unfortunate part of all this is that meritorious and dedicated people lose out while undeserving people get to work for the best law firms. This trend is dangerous especially in India where reference and contacts are critical to how your career shapes up. If you happen to be one of those unfortunate people who dont have contacts then its a difficult climb to the top.
Hatt Raja 1 Dec 2011, 07:05
+0 -0
@#7.........."Nahi Bhaiya, aisa nahi hai"........................its only that merit has to do a lot of slogging which an average law guy with big contacts is able to avoid................So, stop crying and enjoy the slogging...................because that is the best you can do.................
chainamdar 4 Dec 2011, 05:29
+0 -0
PARTIALLY I ADMIT kianganz SENTENCE . I KNOW YOU LOOK AROUND , YOU WILL FIND corruption. but it doesn't mean that every rich daddy's boy get high position in everywhere. if you have guts , then you can do everything. struggle tar struggle .
GK 6 Dec 2011, 05:15
+0 -0
The concern isn't narrowly restricted to ONLY law firms in India. It's noticeable in all industries. An elite super-class is born and is growing uncontrollably all over the world (Read the link). The mantra nowadays is not what Biblical (Mathew 6:3) saying 'the left shouldn't know what the right does' goes. The son should know what the daddy does or the vice versa.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2011/dec/05/income-inequality-growing-faster-uk
~AK~ 21 Jun 2012, 12:44
+0 -0
so yeah this discrimination exists, I Fell disheartened abut this all the time
What are we supposed to do now?????
Is there any way we can get good jobs without Dady syndrome :\
Jobless Lawyer 3 Apr 2013, 10:22
+0 -0
Can't say. I tried almost everything. Not coming from an NLU, I aimed at the not-so-good firms. the middle tier and newer firms. There clearly is something that I am either doing wrong or not doing at all. Coz I am yet to hear from a law firm. Its been 2 years since I cleared the AIBE.

Somewhere I guess the problem lies with me. My problem of not being able to "seek someone's help" or "ask for work" from those I worked with during my internships. I find myself at a loss of words as to how to begin the conversation and what to say. No website gives me tips on "how to break the ice". Its been more than 2-3 years now. I doubt if they'll remember me. The energy or high hopes and aspirations I once had, are all a thing of the past now. Sometimes I wish I hadn't entered this field at all. What's the use of getting good grades all through 10 semesters, doing internships in good enough law firms, clearing AIBE when I still haven't got that "one" opportunity?