Rs 50+ L rent, Rs 2+ cr deposit: Shardul Amarchand moves into new Mumbai office with space for 140

Express Towers: Getting fashionable again
Express Towers: Getting fashionable again

Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas moved into its now-renovated 23rd, 24th and 17th floors of its Express Towers offices late last month.

The firm’s Mumbai managing partner Akshay Chudasama, who officially joined Shardul Amarchand on 25 May 2015, confirmed that the Mumbai office had been based in the Nariman Point-based Express Towers since opening in the city and that the firm had leased the 23rd and half of the 24th and 17th floors in the building.

While those three floors were still being renovated, the firm’s new office was based on other floors in the building temporarily.

Chudasama said that the current headcount was around 80 lawyers in Mumbai, though the new offices had seating space for a total of 140.

Shardul Amarchand had entered into two lease agreements with Indian Express Newspapers (Mumbai) Pvt Ltd last year via two partners – Shardul Shroff and Akshay Chudasama.

The first was entered into by Shardul Shroff, while the second agreement was entered into by Mumbai managing partner Chudasama on September 15, according to the contract available with the local property registry.

24th half-floor

The first leave and license agreement was signed on 23 July for an area of 8,668 square feet on the 24th floor of the building, which Legally India understands is around half the available space on that floor.

It is a five-year lease with a monthly rental of Rs 15.169 lakh for the first 36 months (three years) and thereafter a 15 per cent increase in the rental costs for the next 24 months (two years).

The deposit paid for this deal was Rs 65.79 lakh, according to the agreement.

The signatories to this deal are Dhillon Pereira of the Express Group, and Shardul Shroff. The stamp duty paid for this deal is Rs 2.5 lakh.

23rd floor

The later lease agreement was signed for a space of 16,572 square feet.

The monthly rental for this was around Rs 29 lakh.

The deposit for the deal was roughly Rs 1.26 crore.

Pereira remained the signatory on this deal from the Express group, while for Shardul Amarchand the signatory was Chudasama.

The stamp duty paid for the deal was Rs 5.53 lakh.

Legally India did not have access to the papers for half of the 17th floor, but if rates are similar as for the 24th floor, that would work out to a monthly rent of at least Rs 59 lakh, and a total deposit of at least Rs 2.56 crore.

Shardul Amarchand in Mumbai also has a litigation office in the Fort area’s Lentin Chambers, near the Bombay high court.

Express Towers had seen an exodus of law firms to mid-town in recent years, with AZB & Partners having been the most recent to move out of the iconic building to Lower Parel, following DSK Legal in 2010.

ALMT Legal remains in Express Towers, having secured additional floors in recent years.

The original partnership firm Amarchand Mangaldas Suresh A Shroff & Co was dissolved on 9 May 2015, with both erstwhile Amarchand Mangaldas managing partners and Shroff brothers setting up new, independent firms.

Shardul launched his firm on May 10, while Cyril Shroff launched his new firm Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas a day later on May 11.

Comments

Huh 22 Jan 2016, 14:28
+25 -0
They have more space than Zia and are only seating 140 lawyers? Zia had almost 300 crammed in the same space!!
Either Chudasama is way off or Zia was running a sweat shop.... Well both could be true!
Guest 22 Jan 2016, 16:27
+2 -0
Did Sam con cam into thinking that they were opening an office in Bangalore so that cam over leverages itself in the south? Just thinking aloud.
Guest 22 Jan 2016, 16:38
+1 -2
Why hasn't my comment been published?
volante 22 Jan 2016, 16:49
+1 -0
SAM & CAM both have their litigation offices at Lentin Chambers i believe!
Rentalwala 22 Jan 2016, 16:52
+5 -0
Kian, why not report what kind of rentals the other firms are paying?
daruwala 23 Jan 2016, 02:01
+0 -0
And to whom?
kianganz 24 Jan 2016, 15:35
+2 -0
Yes, would definitely be interesting, been thinking about it...
Dv compare 22 Jan 2016, 22:43
+24 -0
Gimme the lease agreements for cam n azb. Let me do a dv compare and see who has a better deal!! If I can read an analysis of Sam's lease, let me review the others too.. Is LI going to do a title search for other law firm properties too? You'll might just beat kanga and hariani in title search and title reports!!
Kian is watching 23 Jan 2016, 04:22
+92 -3
Thanks Kian for the info. Really changed my life. Been waiting for the details since forever. We need more people like you. Am I being too greedy if I'm asking you to also check if the adequate stamp duty was paid?
NLUJ 23 Jan 2016, 04:25
+38 -2
Boss! - Please raise the standards of legal journalism. What is the point of this story? BTW, has SAM stooped to the level of this kind of reporting?
Wham! Make it BIG 23 Jan 2016, 05:25
+21 -3
When you dont have anything but money... you will ONLY talk about money.. and nothing else.
Whats new in this lease? Nothing exceptional. Its just another law firm in another commercial building paying top dollar or maybe not. Who cares? Lets see what they bring to the table.
Soup 26 Jan 2016, 15:16
+0 -1
Thus far the table is empty
Anon1 28 Jan 2016, 04:02
+3 -2
And which part of the article made you believe that SAM is talking about money or supplying information to LI.

Its LI which has obtained information from the lease deeds and posted here for everyone to see! Or are you just jealous and won't loose a single opportunity to bash!

Which table are you referring to? I assume nothing reached your table :)
No comments yet 23 Jan 2016, 06:55
+17 -20
While SAM was busy signing lease deeds and moving to new office spaces, Khaitan and AZB closed 4 M&A deals. #justsaying
Chotta Don 23 Jan 2016, 08:04
+2 -1
Thank you Kian Bhai, aab aapun ko pata hai aage kiska settee bajane ka hai...
Orknob 23 Jan 2016, 12:20
+42 -3
Kian, how many loos does SAM operate in Express Towers? Please please do say.... The Nation Wants to Know, Kian, the Nation Wants to Know...!
Guest 24 Jan 2016, 06:34
+0 -1
haha let's see them hire the other 60 lawyers soon that's what should be seen as news....
kianganz 24 Jan 2016, 15:36
+4 -0
I don't know, I'm sure someone can confirm for several firms, then we can calculate the best and worst associate/toilets ratios...
Bloody Mary 24 Jan 2016, 10:55
+3 -1
Kian - while I am not too sure what value this article adds, I am just wondering why would you do an article like this without getting the same information for other premier firms and then putting up an industry picture or a comparative study. Currently this article seems very out-of-place and without any context. Wish you had done an industry study on this.
kianganz 24 Jan 2016, 15:40
+1 -9
Hi Bloody Mary,

This article was published since Bapu Deedwania painstakingly obtained the records for these leases.

I agree, it'd be great to do the same kind of data for other firms, though as I understand it, the property registry in Maharashtra can be slightly user-unfriendly and operate mostly in Marathi.

If any property lawyers want to give some advice on how best to go about it, do please share.

Other than that, I don't think the article is useless without comparative information, as it's a useful exercise in bringing more transparency into law firm finances, etc.

And as #13 says below, the investment by SAM in Mumbai is interesting for others in the industry.

Plus, I've given a few more reasons for why it's worth reading in our email newsletter from today: http://www.legallyindia.com/newsletters/long-expected-projects-parties-newsletter-issue-127
Kian is watching 24 Jan 2016, 16:45
+3 -0
Of course he will painstakingly obtain the lease deeds. His surname is 'deed'wania. Does not mean that all his deeds are published on legally India (like my troll-ish comments). JK.
kianganz 24 Jan 2016, 16:47
+1 -0
Points for the pun! But Bapu's a she, not a he :)
Kian is watching 24 Jan 2016, 18:07
+0 -0
Oops
---- 24 Jan 2016, 11:16
+15 -0
I don't see anything wrong in this report. After the split, which has caused a turmoil in the legal market, the manner in which CAM and SAM go on with their business is a matter of interest to some - if not all.

Place of office, rent and other expenses are relevant in expansion of new firms - which SAM and CAM are, despite the legacy.

If you don't like it - don't read it. Don't blame Kian.

And if you need a target to do so - go after times of india.
Kian is watching 24 Jan 2016, 14:14
+4 -1
Are you indirectly calling me intolerant?

I will not tolerate this. Absolutely not.
kianganz 24 Jan 2016, 15:42
+1 -0
Thanks, agree.

As a follow-up, the firms I'd really be interested in seeing property papers for would be some of the old Bombay firms.

I hear some of them pay pittances in rent and can't be evicted by landlords including SBI or so in one case, which is an undoubted business advantage compared to other firms renting in India Bulls.

Though some of these low-rent offices also look like the landlord has stopped caring about maintenance :)
Vanquish 26 Jan 2016, 13:49
+2 -0
Kian, you are right. Crawford Bayley pays a pittance in rent for their 10,000 sq feet + office. SBI wants them thrown out. There is litigation going on between them in Bombay HC regarding this i believe since last year.
kianganz 27 Jan 2016, 19:35
+1 -0
Little & Co has also been semi squatting on some SBI land or so, no?
WG 27 Jan 2016, 11:02
+1 -0
Wadia Ghandy pays Rs. 100 or thereabouts for its lease to Wadia Charities.
kianganz 27 Jan 2016, 19:36
+0 -0
Wadia Charities owns their property? Seems like a nice arrangement - these old money firms have a massive advantage in Mumbai, rent wise...
Advantage? 28 Jan 2016, 07:59
+0 -2
Kian its not really an advantage 50 Lakhs is equal to a Sr. Associates Salary. Not really much of a financial advantage given the number of people that get hired in law firms.
kianganz 28 Jan 2016, 09:11
+3 -0
I really want to meet the senior associate who gets more than Rs 50 lakhs per MONTH and ask him or her to give me presents! :)
Anonymouse 24 Jan 2016, 11:29
+5 -5
Interesting. Heard about a mass exhodus in their banking and finance team. I wonder how chuda and gang from JSA are okay with following and imposing the 18 hour a day SAM work culture after how things were run at JSA.
Airlift 24 Jan 2016, 12:06
+15 -2
LI also share electricity and water bill. Do comparison of lease rent, electricity and water bill paid by first 10 law firms.
Insider 24 Jan 2016, 17:31
+5 -1
ELP pays 10 lac per month for their new, New Delhi office.

FYI
Bengalooru 24 Jan 2016, 19:57
+5 -2
This report is an eye opener for bengalooru based boutique firms that they cannot even think of having an office in Mumbai...
hk lawyer 25 Jan 2016, 17:58
+5 -1
i visited the SAM office as a client today. it is one of the best law offices in the asia region, incredible views and technology in place. SS is going places in leadership.
@hk lawyer 27 Jan 2016, 09:07
+5 -8
did you visit the toilet on the 24th? Heard that a turd was stuck there. Might have been some stink.
also for better view may I recommend the following places :
- gateway of india (beside the inside of the second pillar)
- Hotel Diana (Santa Cruz)
- 30 Cross Road, behind the banyan tree next to the Harley Showroom

Btw, Hotel Diana is run by ex gunman Bheem Paswan of the Shakeel faction. It is doing great profits over last 10 years having started from rags. Also an example of great leadership.

PS: Bheem Paswan is also in the same line as SS. He may do your job for a little less.
@ @hk lawyer 27 Jan 2016, 11:33
+2 -1
I thought here we're discussing about views, technology and leadership in the context of a law firm...

Views and leadership, in other context, there are many many far more better than the 3/4 that you have listed!

Cheers, buddy!
Commentator123 27 Jan 2016, 15:15
+0 -1
Kian- what comments do you allow. Are you simply allowing this for the sake of getting more comments? This is in bad taste and should not be allowed. You need not publish this but it's for your reference.
kianganz 27 Jan 2016, 19:38
+5 -1
There's no accounting for taste, do you really want us to be the arbiter of whether comments are in good taste?

Just sounds like harmless banter to me, though I'm having a hard time making sense of what it even means.
Popatlal 28 Jan 2016, 12:27
+0 -0
@@hk lawyer - Cyril, is that you?
Reply to Popatlal 29 Jan 2016, 06:51
+0 -0
that comment appears to be going in favour of SS, so this can't be Cyril, obviously!

Stupid!