Articles tagged with: freedom of speech

Penguin statement in full: ‘Intolerant’ laws, particularly 295A IPC, made us pulp Doniger’s book

Penguin India has released a statement, blaming section 295A of the Indian Penal Code, which bans “outraging the religious feelings of any class of citizens” with “malicious intent”.

Need to know: Madras HC chief Agrawal talks candidly on local turmoil | Gov blocks 1299 social URLs | Gujarat prisoners UIDed | 3 Bihar district judges dismissed | JAC controversial clause dropped

Madras HC chief Agrawal talks candidly on local turmoil : Recently elevated Madras HC chief justice RK Agrawal, at his farewell, made reference to HC justice CS Karnan barging into his chamber hurling abuse. Agrawal said that while nobody had “ever raised their voice” to him in his 37 year career, K...

Could Penguin have won? Is Hinduism a soft target? Can a virgin give birth to a baby? Kian Ganz in Q&A with CNN-IBN viewers

Kian Ganz
Kian Ganz
Legally India editor Kian Ganz was in an online Q&A today, fielding some excellent and insightful questions on freedom of speech for an hour from CNN-IBN’s viewers. It was fun! Do read and let us know your thoughts.

Doniger blames Indian laws as Penguin’s ‘banned’ book sales skyrocket | Join LI ed Kian Ganz in live chat on CNN-IBN website at 5pm

The media, in India and abroad, has predictably had a field day over the settlement Penguin India entered into to recall and destroy all India-based copies of Wendy Doniger’s book, The Hindus: An Alternative History , against which a religious organisation filed criminal and civil cases. The Mint ca...

Penguin settles religious conservatives’ civil & criminal cases by pulping book of Hindu history

The Hindus
The Hindus
In settlement of a civil and two criminal suits brought by a religious group against Penguin Books India, the publisher has agreed to withdraw and destroy all copies of a history book on Hinduism.

How journalists keep losing to judges: The Swatanter Kumar gag and 4 other chilling times media lost to bench

The chilling effect of the Delhi high court’s gag order it the Swatanter Kumar case is only the latest in a long line of examples of the media losing out in its fight to report on the judiciary, argues advocate Prashant Reddy.

HC’s Swatanter Kumar semi-gag order ‘very worrying’: Chinmayi Arun in Hindu

The Delhi high court’s order, restricting media coverage of the sexual harassment allegations against Swatanter Kumar, should give the Supreme Court cause to consider its Sahara gag order decision, argues Chinamyi Arun, research director at the Centre for Communication Governance at NLU Delhi and fellow at the CIS Bangalore.

Latest Karanjawala-Swatanter Kumar photo takedown reply & LI counter: Response awaited

Judge in Robes
Judge in Robes
After sending a takedown request for a photograph last Thursday, Karanjawala & Co, representing ex-SC judge Swatanter Kumar in a defamation case, declined to specify which parts of Legally India’s coverage relating to the case should be removed.

Karanjawala & Co issues takedown notice of pixellated Swatanter Kumar photo, relying on HC injunction

Artist's impression
Artist's impression
Karanjawala & Co, the law firm representing Swatanter Kumar in his Rs 5 crore defamation suit, has sent Legally India a legal notice for the removal of an anonyised photograph of the ex-judge.

Wired: NLS alum writes myth novel | TOI didn’t defame | SC Tarun Chatterjee to UP HRC | Dec 16 rape confirmation | Law school paycheques

Lawyer myths: NLSIU Bangalore grad and Singapore’s Nanyang Tech B-school lecturer Krishna Udayasankar has penned down a mythological trilogy – the Aryavarta Chronicles. Interview by [ Bangalore Mirror ] TOI didn’t defame: The Times of India is off the hook for criminal defamation after the Madras HC...

Wired: Karnataka govt pleader overhaul | India net freedoms decline most | Juvenile justice | Judges’ retirement age writ dismissed | Lawyer protest | Lawyers stage walk-out

Karnataka govt pleader overhaul: The Karnataka government is on a warpath with its state legal team after it prepared a list of replacements for 61 out of its 73 law officers. While 36 officers resigned without putting up a fight, the rest of them is daring the state government to dismiss them [ Ban...

Chinmayi Arun, Aman Lekhi, Kian Ganz debate Indian internet laws on Newslaundry

Chinmayi Arun, NLU Delhi’s research director at the centre for communication governance, senior advocate Aman Lekhi and Legally India editor Kian Ganz talk “internet laws around the world” in a panel discussion hosted by Newslaundry’s Madhu Trehan. Should India’s IT Act be amended? Lekhi says, not r...

Wired: Bradley Manning gets 35 years | File RTI online | Delhi gang-rape close

File RTI online : Gov launches online portal for filing Right to Information (RTI) requests with 82 ministries at www.rtionline.gov.in [ Firstpost ] Delhi gang-rape closings : The closing arguments in the so-called Delhi gang-rape trial will be heard today. WSJ summarises case so far. Wikileaker sen...

Media friendlier new CJI | Arbitrary CAG challenge heard | OBC state college | Sahara where art thou? | SC presumes v gang rape consent | Salman trial frenzy | Bear witness to Ambani | AP Shah for RTI

Media friendlier new CJI? New CJI P Sathasivam said in a speech that he was in favour of self-regulation of the media rather than strict controls [ Hindu ] His remarks follow both his predecessors’ significant fall-outs with the media – SH Kapadia constituted a constitutional bench into media conduc...

Wired: No Reliance on reportage | Feel you once, shame on me | IPL PIL | CCI all grown up | DoT demands promotion

No Reliance on reportage: Anil Ambani’s ADAG threatened legal action against monthly magazine Caravan while they were reporting their 11,000-word profile on attorney general Goolam Vahanvati. Delhi law firm Agarwal & Associates acted for ADAG, The Hoot published the deets. Feel me once, shame o...

Times threatens legal action v SpicyIP blogger over Financial Times dispute

Spicy IP blogger and NUJS Kolkata student Aparajita Lath was sent a letter threatening a defamation suit by the Times Publishing House, for her post that summarised the 19-year-old dispute between the Times Group and the UK’s Financial Times newspaper. [ SpicyIP ] The notice threatening civil and cr...

Wired: TRAI-ing new approach | Facebook arrest | NLU targets | SEBI’s grey options | Sibal to-do

TRAI-ing new approach: On enforcing the 12 min/hour advertising cap on TV, Telecom Regulatory Authority of India head Rahul Khullar says: “I don’t have to win a fucking election. I am a regulator, I am answerable to Parliament, my job is to enforce the law. Once the regulation is issued, it is law. ...

Courts lift gag on SCC owner to publicise interim win v Lexis, Westlaw

SCC
SCC
The Allahabad High Court (HC) and a Lucknow district court cleared Supreme Court Cases (SCC) publisher EBC to publicise its earlier court win.

IT Dept to appeal IIPM block as social media outrages

Communications minister Kapil Sibal has instructed the Information Technology (IT) department to appeal against the 14 Feb Gwalior court order blocking almost 80 web pages critical of the Arindam Chaudhary owned management institute IIPM. Sources told the Times of India that the department of teleco...

SCBA prez Krishnamani to take B’lore police to task for attacking son’s nude-goddess art

Recently-elected Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) president and senior advocate MN Krishnamani has vowed to file cases for his digital-artist son Anirudh Krishnamani against the Karnataka state government and a Bangalore art gallery, which withdrew the son’s exhibited paintings on the direction ...