Articles tagged with: freedom of speech

CJI pleased with PIL vs IT Act by law-student-to-be from family of illustrious female lawyers

Facebook: Like!
Facebook: Like!
21-year old law aspirant Shreya Singhal, a graduate in astrophysics from the UK’s Bristol University, daughter of Supreme Court advocate Manali Singhal and grand daughter of the late Delhi high court judge Justice Sunanda Bhandare, challenged section 66A of the Information Technology Act in the Supreme Court today under which two women were booked for a comment critical of Bal Thackeray on Facebook 10 days ago.

Woman disrespects Bal bandh on Facebook, friend ‘likes’: both arrested under IPC & IT Act, Katju threatens CM

Liking things online is dangerous
Liking things online is dangerous
A 21-year-old woman and her friend were arrested for allegedly posting and endorsing a comment on Facebook that was critical of the two-day bandh following the death of Mumbai politician Bal Thackeray on Saturday, according to several independent media reports.

India tops Google censorship index: Court takedowns up 300%; Gov seeks 3,500 users’ data

Google transparency
Google transparency
The Indian courts made 20 orders for the removal of 487 content items hosted on the internet by Google services between January and June 2012, setting a new record and keeping India’s second global place in Google’s internet censorship rankings, as the executive asked for personal data on 3,467 users of Google services.

Riveting: Newslaundry grills Katju on teeth, freedom of speech & Indian fools; Katju bites back

{youtube}Po8iuvy_Q9w|450|320{/youtube}

Current affairs, media and culture blog Newslaundry’s Madhu Trehan asks former Supreme Court Justice Markandey Katju, now the chairman of the Press Council of India (PCI), some tough questions about himself and freedom of speech (46 minute video interview). Is Katju’s bark not already bad enough, she asks, that you need more bite? As the interview proceeds, Katju’s fuse is lit several times, and barks and giggles ensue. Click through for a potted digest…

Case report war continues: Lexis Nexis injuncts EBC from publicising own injunction

Publisher Lexis Nexis has obtained an injunction in the Lucknow District Court against Eastern Book Company (EBC) to prevent it from publicising that it was granted an interim injunction in the same court last month against Lexis Nexis for alleged plagiarism.

Delhi HC declines interim injunction in SpicyIP–Natco Defamation case

Whoever said IP was not spicy enough?
Whoever said IP was not spicy enough?
Exclusive: The Delhi high court on Tuesday declined to grant interim injunction to pharma major Natco in its case of defamation against NUJS Kolkata professor and intellectual property blog SpicyIP’s founder Shamnad Basheer.

Column: How free should we be to speak in India?

Kian Ganz
Kian Ganz
Freedom of speech is impossible to agree about. While hardly anyone will dispute that freedom of expression is essential for a democratic society and an effective free market, almost no one will be able to agree about exactly where to draw the line.

In one corner, fighting for unbridled expression in various degrees, you have a disparate group that may include various shades of liberals and conservatives, freedom fighters, anarchists, journalists, academics, libertarians, criminals, terrorists, artists, copyright pirates, pornographers and paedophiles.

A short history of Indian freedom of speech laws: who should we blame?

LI and Mint, together every fortnight
LI and Mint, together every fortnight
Today’s Legally India page in Mint: The typical citizen could be forgiven for fearing that the world’s largest democracy is hurtling towards George Orwell’s 1984 rather than 2013.

SC media trial chilling effect: Will trial reporting postponement orders become default litigation strategy?

Livemint: Have a look at shiny new Livemint.com
Livemint: Have a look at shiny new Livemint.com
In today’s edition of Mint: The good news for those who deal in news is that the Supreme Court decided against framing guidelines for covering so-called sub judice matters, or those before the courts.

The bad news is that by delivering what some analysts are calling an ambiguous judgement, the apex court may have well made it easier to muzzle the media and, far worse, institutionalized the process by which individuals and entities fighting cases can ensure that these aren’t covered till the order is passed.

Del HC questions locus of internet users to defend Article 19 right in posting content

Who owns the Internet?
Who owns the Internet?
Four practising Supreme Court advocates are set to challenge the Delhi high court’s dismissal last week of their public interest litigation (PIL) challenging the Information Technology Act (IT Act) and Rules (Intermediaries Guidelines) and the government’s August order blocking hundreds of webpages, under the constitutional guarantee of freedom of speech and expression.

Breaking media trial debate: SC allows temporary court reporting gag to prevent contempt, shies away from regulation

Supreme Court: Upholds free speech, with delays
Supreme Court: Upholds free speech, with delays
The Supreme Court today laid down a new doctrine that, if requested, would allow courts to temporarily ban media from reporting a case if it would adversely affect the trial, but the special constitutional bench of five judges declined to create wider guidelines on how the media should report court cases.

Twitter, Facebook and YouTube account holders faced with gov’t legal notices for inciting Assam violence

Government sends legal notices to account holder on Twitter, YouTube and Facebook who allegedly posted on their webpage inflammatory messages and morphed images related to ethnic violence in Assam. Notices have been sent to “at least four” Twitter account holders, asking them to appear before a comm...

Delhi HC turns down law students’ plea to unblock URLs blocked by DoT in August, follows SC turn-down

The Delhi high court dismissed a public interest litigation filed by a group of law students to quash the department of telecommunications’ notifications last month blocking hundreds of webpages , on Wednesday. The Supreme Court had also returned a petition challenging the block on 31 August, asking...

Natco sues SpicyIP’s Shamnad Basheer for Rs 25 lakh defamation

spicyip logo
spicyip logo
Exclusive: Pharmaceutical company Natco has filed in the Delhi high court against intellectual property (IP) blog SpicyIP, claiming that the website published an article that allegedly contained “false, derogatory and defamatory” statements about the company.

Govt goes on August net blocking frenzy of 100s of URLs

The Ministry of Communications and IT, Department of Telecommunications on Saturday directed ISPs to block 76 webpages, including 10 handles on micro-blogging site Twitter, 12 pages on video-sharing site YouTube, 14 Facebook profiles, and blogs and other pages with religion-related content. The orde...

DH Law bigger Mumbai office | SC: Lawyers violent, helmets for judges? | Soli Sorabjee: Judicial activism & pet octopodes | JSA Potdar: Independent directors – from pillar to post | Abolish law reviews | Sports manager Tarun Mehrishi & more…

DH Law offices moves to a bigger, 3500 sq feet office space with “superior facilities” in Free Press House (FPH) Nariman Point from it’s earlier smaller Nariman Point space, said managing partner Nusrat Hassan. The firm launched formally in Delhi and Patna on 1 July 2012 SC attacks violent conduct o...

Telecom tribunal split-verdict on 3G | CCI– businesses’ mom-in-law | RTI revealing website block fraud | DHC ex-parte patent injunction | Herbies goes NYC | A&O, CC profits up | IT e-filing…

Telecom companies cannot legally enter into an agreement to provide 3G roaming services if they do not have a licence, rules telecom tribunal in split-verdict between TDSAT chairman and another adjudicator. Verdict split over sending fresh notices to the concerned telcos or terminating their pacts i...

Kapil Sibal & Co shoot down motion to kill IT Rules: cite terrorism, drugs

Kapil Sibal looks for Internet spring clean of objectionable content
Kapil Sibal looks for Internet spring clean of objectionable content
The Information Technology (Intermediaries Guidelines) Rules 2011 (The Rules) continue to breathe after the statutory motion to annul them moved by member of parliament (MP) from Kerala P Rajeeve was defeated by voice vote in the Rajya Sabha yesterday.

Telecom Minister Kapil Sibal was heard on Rajya Sabha TV saying: “We are more liberal than US and Europe but let’s not cut our arms.”

MPs to be taught ‘draconian’ IT Act Rules as India.net support galvanises for annul motion

Who owns the Internet?
Who owns the Internet?
Rajya Sabha’s member of parliament (MP) from Kerala, P Rajeeve, whose statutory motion to annul the IT (Intermediaries Guidelines) Rules 2011 is slated for discussion in Parliament tomorrow, aims to convene a meeting of MPs, internet societies, and bloggers in the first week of May to create awareness against the draconian effect of the rules.

Everyone’s seen the ‘alleged’ sex tape. Should you?

image
image
Everyone’s talking about the cat that accidentally got out of the bag. Private screenings of a video featuring two people are being organised around town.

Reviews have been not been flattering. The video “deserves a PG-13 rating”, says one who saw it. “It’s a bit like a bad Hindi movie which usually shields anything remotely sexual with a flower or some such inane object.”