Verus wins meat for Mumbai, but slaughterhouse to remain closed

Verus won an order lifting the city-wide Mumbai ban on the sale of meat that was imposed by the government in solidarity with the Jain fasting period.

Verus safeguards right to meat
Verus safeguards right to meat

Verus Advocates won an order lifting the city-wide Mumbai ban on the sale of meat that was imposed by the government in solidarity with the Jain fasting period.

Verus partner Charles De Souza and associate Mahima Sinha instructed advocate Zubin Behramkamdin, who acted for the Bombay Mutton Dealer Association (BMDA) in its Bombay high court challenge to the meat ban that was imposed by the state government and the Mumbai Municipal Corporation (MMC) on 10, 13, 17 and 18 September.

Senior advocate Anil Singh was briefed by advocate JS Saluja for the Maharashtra government and senior advocate NV Walawalker was briefed by advocate Geeta Joglekar for the MMC They had issued a circular on 1 September declaring the ban and the closure of one of Asia’s largest slaughterhouses – the Deonar Abbatoir – on the dates of the ban.

The Poultry Breeders Welfare Associate also intervened through senior advocate Vikram Nankani briefed by advocate Ishwar Nankani and Nankani & Associates advocates Huzefa Khokhawala and Gauri Rege.

BMDA’s writ, which was filed on 9 September, was initially assigned to justices AS Oka and VL Achliya, but Justice Achliya recused himself from the case. It was then assigned to a bench of justices AV Mohta and AA Sayed and heard on the evening of 9 September, on the morning of 10 September and throughout the day on 11 September, Verus told Legally India in an email.

On 11 September the MMC informed the court that it was withdrawing its notification banning meat in Mumbai on 13 and 18 September. Against the 17 September meat ban, which was imposed not by the MMC but the state government, Verus won a stay.

Licenced meat shops in municipal and private markets will be open for business on 17 and 18 September now.

However, the slaughterhouse at Deonar will remain shut on 17 September.

The court admitted the BMDA’s challenge and formulated the issues arising in the case, for arguments at the next hearing, however the full text of this order is not yet available.

Meanwhile, the Haryana government, though did not impose a ban but had appealed to slaughterhouses to remain closed for nine days starting 11 September on the account of Paryushan Parva of the Jain community, reported the *Indian Express.

Comments

Kudos 14 Sept 2015, 11:48
+10 -5
Well done Verus and advocate Zubin Behramkamdin ! Would have been great, if the slaughterhouse remained open on 17 September as well. Terrible how the government tries to appease one community by forcing other communities to show obeisance.
Meat Feat - Retreat 14 Sept 2015, 16:16
+5 -5
If I cannot go to my local butcher and get "fresh" meat - slaughtered before my eyes, then what is the big deal in this "win". I could have well stocked up on chicken fillets and lamb cuts in my freezer and hope the dreaded meat-less days to pass.
Mrs Sam 14 Sept 2015, 17:23
+1 -2
Your chicken will be slaughtered before your eyes while larger animals at the abattoir. Wasnt that always the position? Or did ur butcher slaughter in his house? Shhhhh don't answer. Uncle Sam maybe watching.
Meat Feat - Retreat 14 Sept 2015, 18:05
+3 -0
Nope...it was the position earlier, before the ban, I quote from a PTI news story reporting this order of the high court:

"A division bench of Justices Anoop V Mohta and Amjad Sayyed in their order said, "We are staying the ban on sale of meat on September 17, but we are not interfering with the ban on slaughter of meat and closure of abattoirs on that date."

Now, you will ask me: why did the chicken cross the road? I am still meditating on that one....when I am enlightened with the answer I will call you for a chicken curry treat.
Qureshi 14 Sept 2015, 17:54
+6 -1
Power to you my friend! If you have time to watch a slaughter doubt you have much work. Come assist me sometime, might help keep you occupied.
Meat Feat - Retreat 15 Sept 2015, 09:58
+1 -2
Yes, it takes awful long time for chickens and goats to be slaughtered in the HALAL fashion - looks pretty cruel too. Hey, but if you want fresh then you have to make the effort and suffer such pain. And members of our legal tribe are inured to pain of our clients.

While these poor animals bleed to death, yes, maybe I could profitably use this time and bill more. Please set me up for a client call at these times, OK?

BTW I hope you like your meat HALAL. You know it tastes just too good to be kosher!!
Qureshi 15 Sept 2015, 10:26
+2 -0
Oh you don't have clients and want me to set up a client call. Poor you!
Guest 15 Sept 2015, 01:05
+1 -0
At least something else to be secular about. At this rate, european countries are communal quagmires!