Legal opinions

Who will bell the legal cat? Because it probably won't be BCI or judiciary...

xsa1qmaq
xsa1qmaq
The old aphorism that managing lawyers is like herding cats was applied originally to managing partners of law firms trying to control their partnership.

Many good reasons why ex-CBI chief Ranjit Sinha’s 2G meetings must warrant a criminal investigation against him and his secret visitors

Supreme Court advocate KV Dhananjay argues that former CBI director Ranjit Sinha’s clandestine meetings with 2G and Coal scam accused were prima facie illegal.

Listen yaar: What’s the deal with the Delhi high court menopause rape judgment anyway?

LI-Listen-logo
LI-Listen-logo
Listen yaar, the Delhi high court said that women who’ve entered menopause can’t be raped, right?

Opinion: Madras HC anti-RTI judgment will ensure that opacity continues festering in our courts

Madras HC lays another brick in the wall against RTI
Madras HC lays another brick in the wall against RTI
Karnataka advocate @certiorary argues that a recent Madras high court judgment is the latest erosion of transparency in the judiciary, despite the RTI Act, and needs to be fixed at a higher level.

How I realised I’m not ‘being such a girl’ after I was held in a headlock by a colleague

Louboutin
Louboutin
This is a reminder for myself: a reminder that being aware of how I don’t want to be man-handled does not mean I am fussy, or hormonal, or (my favourite) “being such a girl”.

Minority Report is not fiction, PreCrime is now the law in Karnataka

Tom Cruise
Tom Cruise
Supreme Court advocate KV Dhananjay argues that the Karnataka legislature’s amendment to the so-called Goonda’s Act is ‘exceedingly dangerous’.

Why the NJAC legal challenges must fail (for now)

KV Dhananjay
KV Dhananjay
Supreme Court advocate KV Dhananjay argues that the public interest litigations against the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) bill must fail, at least at this point in time…

How Subramanian Swamy managed to resurrect #InternJudge and spin media amnesia into a ‘clean chit’

Kian Ganz explains on Newslaundry how over the last week the papers have been happily running with a news story about how AK Ganguly, the former Supreme Court judge who had allegedly harassed one of his interns after retirement, with headlines such as “Ganguly gets Centre’s clean chit in intern case...

Opinion: To fix the most fundamental problems of the Indian judiciary, we must finish what Fali & others started

*

Prashant Reddy: Listening to Fali
Prashant Reddy: Listening to Fali
*Delhi lawyer Prashant Reddy argues that many of the plans for reforming the Indian courts fail to see the most fundamental problem - a lack of transparency – and proposes several ideas to fixing it.

SC landmark transgender judgment: What it says, what is good and what it muddled up

Nalsar Hyderabad student Anindita Mukherjee analyses today’s Supreme Court judgment recognising the “third gender” and points out what the apex court may have missed.

‘Death for rape’ is not justice but symptom of a society that doesn’t value women

Nandita Saikia
Nandita Saikia
Lawyer Nandita Saikia discusses how the recent criminal law recent reforms, imposing the death penalty for rape, are a symptom of the problem but not a solution.

Why 'eminent jurists' want nothing to do with the Lokpal

The fact that a Lokpal bill did get passed at all, should give pause for thought.

Examining Congress' record on India's lawyers: Could NaMo or Kejri do better? (Spoiler: No)

RaGa: Not a lawyer
RaGa: Not a lawyer
With Lok Sabha elections now scheduled to start on 7 April it is fair to ask: what has the current government done for India’s legal profession? And can any of the others do better?

How the soft Swatanter Kumar gag and Karanjawala’s photo SLAPP are strategic genius and insidiously powerful

Artist's Impression 0
Artist's Impression 0
For all intents and purposes, a lot of credit should go to Karanjawala & Co, for they have proven what difference a lawyer can make (or a team of six or more, judging by the number cc’d to my recent email correspondence with the firm).

Legal league tables explained: How to perform and excel in the vicious / virtuous circus

Role models
Role models
Most lawyers will publicly decry that they have any emotional attachment to their firm’s league table position; in truth (or with time) almost every lawyer ends up caring about it anyway.

HC’s Swatanter Kumar semi-gag order ‘very worrying’: Chinmayi Arun in Hindu

The Delhi high court’s order, restricting media coverage of the sexual harassment allegations against Swatanter Kumar, should give the Supreme Court cause to consider its Sahara gag order decision, argues Chinamyi Arun, research director at the Centre for Communication Governance at NLU Delhi and fellow at the CIS Bangalore.

Why most AK Ganguly defenders miss the point: Politics & media are integral to the ‘trial’

Media trial
Media trial
LI reporter Prachi Shrivastava argues that, to date, the pillars of the Indian constitution have been remarkably efficient and fair in the investigation and reporting of the sexual harassment allegations against former Supreme Court Justice Asok Kumar Ganguly.

The SC’s material errors should enable ‘review petition’ of its #377 judgment

Surabhi Shukla
Surabhi Shukla
Jindal Global Law School (JGLS) senior research associate Surabhi Shukla argues that the Supreme Court made a serious error in its judgment, which would pave the way for a review petition of the judgment.

Opinion: Of mutually stressful media trials, swirling #InternJudge conspiracies and Arnab Goswami

1r413ln2
1r413ln2
Nikhil Kanekal explores the media furore and arguments surrounding the swirling #InternJudge sex harassment case that has thrown media, bench and bar into a tizzy.

Out of a valley of darkness: How, in the face of tyranny, the Supreme Court did right by #InternJudge

vbnacoit
vbnacoit
Those who are accusing the Supreme Court of washing its hands of the allegation that a former apex court judge sexually harassed a former intern (“SJ”), have it wrong.