Legal opinions

Opinion: In one of India’s ‘most sexist professions’, harassment by powerful men is rife

Mihira Sood
Mihira Sood
I have wanted to write some of these things at different times since it happened, and always shied away, argues Mihira Sood, gathering the courage to speak out about sexual harassment in the courts.

Law firmite rebuts GC’s ramblings: Law firms do and will continue to generate value

*

Dothraki rainmaker
Dothraki rainmaker
*A law firm pro has penned a response to the controversial Ramblings of a GC column from last week.

Ramblings of a GC & former BigLaw associate: Law firms don’t add value, they destroy it

Burning money
Burning money
While hourly rates continue to increase and add up, the quality of India’s legal advice unfortunately continues to spiral downwards. Affronted? Well, you should be.

Of paid news, ‘leading players’ and ‘editorial content’: How Indian law firms advertise

Advertising
Advertising
So, Legally India sometimes gets accidentally addressed mail making us privy to some of the less public proposals law firms receive.

Sex, marriage, gender: If judges mean well, why do they sometimes talk so badly?

Monday’s Madras high court judgment by Justice Karnan caused debate, outrage and counter-outrage in and between traditional, new and social media, which unfortunately missed the wood for the trees, argues Prachi Shrivastava.

On dealing with spam emails without the law: India’s lack of data protection rules

LI and Mint, together every fortnight
LI and Mint, together every fortnight
In last week’s Mint: Travel site Cleartrip landed a massive PR victory and garnered lots of Internet brownie points this month, ironically after firing its PR company.

Study reveals ‘mobbing culture’ at law firms: How bosses cause tears & competition

LI and Mint, together every fortnight
LI and Mint, together every fortnight
In today’s edition of Mint: A lot of Indian law firms are run like the personal fiefdom of a senior or founding partner. The senior partners are a law unto themselves and are neither accountable internally nor externally. Such systems can breed unique pressures and cultures, quite separately from associate satisfaction with their salaries.

‘Victim blaming’ frenzy continues as NLSIU faces eviction over rape case, police speculates widely, media buys in

Editorial: Bangalore’s police, media and educators have shown themselves at their worst in the past days, appearing intent to keep slinging mud on a law school student who was allegedly the victim of a violent sex crime.

Column: Judges are people too

Humans
Humans

A lot of the recent frictions between the judiciary and the media are little more than misunderstandings, argues Kian Ganz.

Column: How free should we be to speak in India?

Kian Ganz
Kian Ganz
Freedom of speech is impossible to agree about. While hardly anyone will dispute that freedom of expression is essential for a democratic society and an effective free market, almost no one will be able to agree about exactly where to draw the line.

In one corner, fighting for unbridled expression in various degrees, you have a disparate group that may include various shades of liberals and conservatives, freedom fighters, anarchists, journalists, academics, libertarians, criminals, terrorists, artists, copyright pirates, pornographers and paedophiles.

Mint column: Legal ads vs legal journalism

washing-powder
washing-powder
The other day a public relations (PR) agency called me and said that it really wanted an article written for Mint about one of its clients, a fairly well known Delhi lawyer. They said they wanted an interview with or a quote from that lawyer to appear by next week and they would arrange a meeting as soon as possible. As far as pitches for stories go, it was pretty weak.

The plight of excellent young lawyers, why they leave, and the art of rainmaking

LI and Mint, together every fortnight
LI and Mint, together every fortnight
In today’s edition of Mint: The Indian lawyers’ pie may be large but taking the first nibble is often the hardest part.

The Mint-LI Column: Lawyers, propagating the worst aspects of Indian bureaucracy

LI and Mint, together every fortnight
LI and Mint, together every fortnight
In today’s edition of Mint: On the face of it, my mission was the simplest of tasks possible within the legal system: to get an affidavit. I needed the sworn document proving my identity and address to sign up for a Bharatgas connection. In going the sworn path, I also went against the well-meaning advice of those who told me that getting a gas cylinder from the grey market was easier.

Opinion: Most law firms and their websites are in ‘blatant violation’ of BCI advertising rules

BCI website: Needs some work
BCI website: Needs some work
Either the Bar Council of India (BCI) should censure dozens of law firms for their singing and dancing websites, or it needs to be realistic and relax its strict advertising restrictions, argues Raghul Sudheesh.

Opinion: Crisis of teaching at India’s law schools

LI and Mint, together every fortnight
LI and Mint, together every fortnight
In today’s edition of Mint: The success story of the NLU model has been spun mainly around two factors: the impressive employment statistics and enormous salaries offered to students from top NLUs and the ability of few alumni to gain admission to the world’s top law school, argue Anup Surendranath and Chinmayi Arun.

Everyone’s seen the ‘alleged’ sex tape. Should you?

image
image
Everyone’s talking about the cat that accidentally got out of the bag. Private screenings of a video featuring two people are being organised around town.

Reviews have been not been flattering. The video “deserves a PG-13 rating”, says one who saw it. “It’s a bit like a bad Hindi movie which usually shields anything remotely sexual with a flower or some such inane object.”

An unfair battle: Translating the journalist’s trade to lawyers and lordships

LI and Mint, together every fortnight
LI and Mint, together every fortnight
Mint legal correspondent Nikhil Kanekal argues in today’s legal page in the paper that the hearing the Supreme Court is waging against the media, is fundamentally unfair and misunderstands the trade of journalism, as lawyers and judges are often wont to.

The Rule of Lawyers: Examining legal advisers’ de facto legal immunity in India

LegallyIndia_KianGanz-col
LegallyIndia_KianGanz-col
Mint column: Lawyers should be the noble and independent servants of justice, the courts and their clients. Finding lawyers who do all three of those things is the exception, rather than the rule.

For starters, Indian clients have very little, if any, recourse against lawyers who give them bad, negligent or harmful legal advice, as explained in today’s Mint feature. But that is just the tip of lawyers’ legal immunity iceberg.

Opinion: Why the Budget’s shots at Vodafone should be seen as a constitutional crisis

LI and Mint, together every fortnight
LI and Mint, together every fortnight
A corollary of the Rule of Law is that legislation with retrospective effect is highly dubious, argues Kian Ganz. The latest budget proposals to tax offshore transactions going back to 1962, is a worrying sign of the kind of country India wants to be.

Opinion: Strip BCI of powers over legal education & ‘noble’ professional regulation

In Mint today: BCI is not an effective regulator
In Mint today: BCI is not an effective regulator
Mint’s Nikhil Kanekal argues in today’s edition of Mint that the Bar Council of India (BCI) should be stripped of most of its powers and replaced with an independent regulators who can better oversee legal education and the noble profession.