Articles tagged with: National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC)

SC collegium goes (much more) transparent, begins posting biz online: But will it last, unlike asset disclosures?

The Supreme Court’s collegium of Chief Justice of India (CJI) Dipak Misra and the next senior-most judges, justices J Chelameswar, Ranjan Gogoi, Madan B Lokur and Kurian Joseph, have begun to post recommendations for elevations and other business on a new ‘resolutions of the collegium’ section of its website according to minutes dated 3 October.

Contrary to earlier reports, collegium maybe never agreed to Gov’t ‘national security’ veto • So, let’s wildly speculate what’s going on

And here’s one of the problems with the opaque collegium and judiciary, which rarely if ever officially confirms anything to journalists, leaving reporting on the bench to often be sourced on hints and whispers.

The collegium has already been compromised by executive power (and opacity), argues Dushyant Dave

Senior counsel Dushyant Dave, writing in The Wire, has criticised a number of recent decisions of the Supreme Court regarding judicial elevations and transfers, for having been as opaque (as ever) and having missed out on obvious candidates, suggesting that executive pressure scuppered the elevations of several judges who’d handed down decisions the government wouldn’t have liked.

Future post-NJAC judges having to pass ‘national security’ test is a dangerous can of worms

The Supreme Court collegium has finally completed its year-long-awaited draft of the memorandum of procedure (MOP), which would govern how judges are appointed in future, reported the The Times of India’s Dhananjay Mahapatra earlier today:

Although pendency hasn’t really suffered, pragmatism wins the day: Trickle of 5 new SC judges gets approved after a year

With the last batch of Supreme Court elevations having been made only in May 2016 with four new judges (who had been recommended in December 2015), the collegium’s latest recommendations of five new Supreme Court judges were cleared by the president yesterday.

In bid to break post-NJAC appointments crisis, SC collegium recommends 9 permanent HC chief justices

The SC collegium has reportedly recommended that the following judges become permanent high court chief justices, according to the Indian Express : Justice Hemant Gupta for Madhya Pradesh High Court; Justice Abhilasha Kumari for Tripura High Court; Justice B D Ahmed for Jammu and Kashmir High Court;...

Law min thinks about making pro bono advocates database to help pick judges • Great, but why not let them apply directly?

The law ministry has asked Bar Council of India (BCI) chairman Manan Kumar Mishra in a letter to help it create a list of lawyers who are willing to act pro bono in cases, which could end up being “one of the proposed yardstick (sic) to be considered for appointment as Judges of High Courts”.

Allegedly ‘short-tempered’ JS Khehar to get quite short 8-month term as Chief Justice of India

Supreme Court Justice JS Khehar has been formally confirmed by the President of India as the next Chief Justice of India (CJI) to succeed Justice TS Thakur and will be the first CJI from the Sikh community, according to the Indian Express.

Legally Explained: Did Justice Chelameswar start a revolution today in the SC collegium?

Justice Jasti Chelameswar, the fifth-most senior judge of the Supreme Court, and a member of the SC’s collegium, made the news today with the New Indian Express publishing his refusal to participate in a Supreme Court collegium meeting, as a protest against the collegium’s failure to comply with the principle of transparency of its proceedings.

CJI Thakur: Dear law minister, judicial appointments must continue - 130 names recommended but pending

Chief Justice of India Justice TS Thakur said on Saturday the process of appointing judges must go on while improving the system, as the delay in appointments will deprive people of their fundamental right of access to justice. He said 130 names recommended from various high courts are in the proces...

Supreme Court says it has no record of its collegium proceedings, dismisses challenge

The Supreme Court bench comprising of justices Ranjan Gogoi, Arun Mishra, and Prafulla C Pant today told Raj Kumar Mehta, the counsel for Lalit Kumar Mishra, the former Additional Judge of the Orissa high court, who challenged his non-appointment as the permanent judge of the high court that there are no records of the proceedings of the Supreme Court collegium.

Blast from the past: Ex-Orissa HC judge challenges his non-appointment as permanent judge in SC, bringing vagaries of old collegium system to the fore

Following last year’s revival of the collegium system of judicial appointments by the Supreme Court’s constitution bench, which quashed the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) last year, the government is all set to revise the existing Memorandum of Procedure for appointment of judges of the Supreme Court and high courts, as suggested by the same bench.

Delhi HC justices Kait, Vaish, Shakdher, Valmiki Mehta transferred out to other high courts

The Supreme Court collegium has transferred four Delhi high court judges to other high courts.

SC to steamroll with 400+5 judge appointments before transparency memorandum

The collegium will not wait for the government’s new procedural guidelines on transparent judicial appointments, to start the process of appointment of 400 new high court judges and five new Supreme Court judges, reported the Hindustan Times . High courts across India are facing 445 judicial vacanci...

Cartoon: SC Finally Makes Decision on Neo-Collegium

Big SCOI day: Neo collegium judgment to be out today as Kerala liquor verdict hangs in balance

The Supreme Court’s five-judge constitution bench headed by Justice JS Khehar is set to pronounce its consequential judgment in the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) case in the morning today (16 December) at Court No 3 at 10:30 AM

The future is now: Smartest bigshots of the bar put some good & different ideas to neo-collegium bench today

SC open to good advice
SC open to good advice
As the Supreme Court’s five-Judge Constitution Bench presided over by Justice JS Khehar began its hearing on reforming the collegium (the in-house mechanism to recruit Judges to the higher judiciary after its recent revival by the same bench) the bench sought advice from counsel on both sides on how to navigate the plethora of diverse proposals which it received.

6 constitutional amendments the SC part-struck-down (but NJAC was the first ever wholesale quash)

As Justice Khehar-led Constitution Bench reassembles today (3 November) to hear proposals for reforming the revived collegium to select judges of the higher judiciary, it cannot help listening to the echoes of its momentous decision to strike down the 99th Amendment Act and the NJAC Act in their entirety, even two weeks after it was delivered on 16 October.

SC AORs: SCAORA, SCBA, new bar body should have a say in neo-collegium

The Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association (SCAORA) has suggested a consultative mechanism comprising judges outside the collegium and representatives of various lawyers bodies for selection of candidates for appointment as apex court and high court judges. The SCAORA in its suggestion for a ...

Two weeks in: NJAC review petition filed

Advocate Mathews J Nedumpara has filed a review petition against the Supreme Court’s decision to strike down the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) Act and the 99th constitutional amendment reported the Times of India . Nedumpara asserts in his petition that the law creating the NJAC d...